Sweep: make all API endpoints idempotent

Here's the PR! https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/pull/56.

⚡ Sweep Basic Tier: I'm using GPT-4. You have 5 GPT-4 tickets left for the month and 3 for the day. (tracking ID: 7a274f093e)

For more GPT-4 tickets, visit our payment portal. For a one week free trial, try Sweep Pro (unlimited GPT-4 tickets).

Actions (click)

[ ] ↻ Restart Sweep

Sandbox Execution ✓

Here are the sandbox execution logs prior to making any changes:

Sandbox logs for d57dea6

npm i 1/4 ✓

added 663 packages, and audited 664 packages in 23s
117 packages are looking for funding
  run `npm fund` for details
3 moderate severity vulnerabilities
To address all issues (including breaking changes), run:
  npm audit fix --force
Run `npm audit` for details.
npm notice 
npm notice New major version of npm available! 9.6.7 -> 10.2.4
npm notice Changelog: 
npm notice Run `npm install -g npm@10.2.4` to update!
npm notice

trunk init 2/4 ✓

⡿ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⡿ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⢿ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⣻ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⣽ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⣾ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⣷ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⣯ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⣟ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⡿ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⢿ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⣻ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⣽ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
⣾ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2...
✔ Downloading Trunk 1.17.2... done
⡿ Verifying Trunk sha256...
✔ Verifying Trunk sha256... done
⡿ Unpacking Trunk...
✔ Unpacking Trunk... done

✔ 10 linters were enabled (.trunk/trunk.yaml)
  actionlint 1.6.26 (3 github-workflow files)
  checkov 3.1.9 (7 json, 9 yaml files)
  eslint 8.54.0 (1 javascript, 17 typescript files)
  git-diff-check (38 files)
  markdownlint 0.37.0 (1 markdown file) (created .markdownlint.yaml)
  osv-scanner 1.4.3 (1 lockfile file)
  prettier 3.1.0 (1 javascript, 6 json, 1 markdown, 17 typescript, 9 yaml files)
  trivy 0.47.0 (9 yaml files)
  trufflehog 3.63.2-rc0 (39 files)
  yamllint 1.33.0 (9 yaml files) (created .yamllint.yaml)
Next Steps
 1. Read documentation
    Our documentation can be found at https://docs.trunk.io
 2. Get help and give feedback
    Join the Trunk community at https://slack.trunk.io

trunk fmt api/api.yml || exit 0 3/4 ✓

Checked 1 file
✔ No issues

trunk check --fix --print-failures api/api.yml 4/4 ✓

Checked 1 file
✔ No issues

Sandbox passed on the latest main, so sandbox checks will be enabled for this issue.

Step 1: 🔎 Searching

I found the following snippets in your repository. I will now analyze these snippets and come up with a plan.

Some code snippets I looked at (click to expand). If some file is missing from here, you can mention the path in the ticket description.

https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/blob/d57dea6bd2514f9bd169b0123c55fc2b57d7c9e3/README.md#L1-L40 https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/blob/d57dea6bd2514f9bd169b0123c55fc2b57d7c9e3/lib/service/Rules.ts#L99-L203

Step 2: ⌨️ Coding

[X] Modify api/api.yml ! No changes made

Modify api/api.yml with contents:
• Review the API specification in this file and identify all endpoints that modify state (POST, PUT, DELETE requests typically).
• For each of these endpoints, add a mechanism to check if the operation has already been performed for the given input. This could be done by storing a hash of the request and checking if the same hash exists before performing the operation.
[X] Ran sandbox for api/api.yml. ✗

Run `api/api.yml` through the sandbox.
[X] Modify lib/controllers/GameController.ts ✓ https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/a3ff5c7cf6b44be90b7d6f64533bb0f1ec22f350

Modify lib/controllers/GameController.ts with contents:
• Modify the controller methods corresponding to the state-modifying endpoints identified in the previous step.
• Implement the logic to check if the operation has already been performed for the given input. If it has, return the same response as the previous request instead of performing the operation again.
[X] Ran sandbox for lib/controllers/GameController.ts. ✗

Sandbox logs for

trunk fmt lib/controllers/GameController.ts || exit 0 1/2 ✓

  FAILURES  
 prettier  lib/controllers/GameController.ts  .trunk/out/sXep3.yaml
  NOTICES  
 A tool failed to run. You can open the details yaml file for more information.
Checked 0 files
✖ No issues, 1 failure

trunk check --fix --print-failures lib/controllers/GameController.ts 2/2 ❌ (`1`)

  ISSUES  
lib/controllers/GameController.ts:35:0
 35:0  high  Parsing error: Declaration or statement expected.  eslint/
  FAILURES  
 prettier  lib/controllers/GameController.ts  .trunk/out/Q3Rdu.yaml
  NOTICES  
 A tool failed to run. You can open the details yaml file for more information.
Checked 1 file
✖ 1 new issue
# .trunk/out/Q3Rdu.yaml
trunk_cli_version: 1.17.2
title: prettier exited with exit_code=2
report:
  - prettier exited with exit_code=2
  - linter:
      command: |
        /root/.cache/trunk/tools/prettier/3.1.0-a552fdee5ef3daae1274e7dca8183c14/node_modules/.bin/prettier -w lib/controllers/GameController.ts
      stdin_path: (none)
      run_from: /tmp/trunk-0/Y8dlw3/FBgEV0
      timeout: 10m
      rerun: (cd /tmp/trunk-0/Y8dlw3/FBgEV0; env -i PATH=/root/.cache/trunk/tools/prettier/3.1.0-a552fdee5ef3daae1274e7dca8183c14/node_modules/.bin:/root/.cache/trunk/tools/node/18.12.1-00ae74f39ac4de3ff3c7e3686016ebf3/bin:/root/.cache/trunk/tools/node/18.12.1-00ae74f39ac4de3ff3c7e3686016ebf3:/root/.nvm/versions/node/v18.17.0/bin/:/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/sbin:/bin HOME=/root NODE_PATH=/root/.cache/trunk/tools/prettier/3.1.0-a552fdee5ef3daae1274e7dca8183c14/node_modules /root/.cache/trunk/tools/prettier/3.1.0-a552fdee5ef3daae1274e7dca8183c14/node_modules/.bin/prettier -w lib/controllers/GameController.ts)
      affects_cache:
        - package.json
      direct_configs:
        []
      exit_status: exited
      exit_code: 2
      stdout: (none)
      stderr: |
        [error] lib/controllers/GameController.ts: SyntaxError: Declaration or statement expected. (35:1)
        [error]   33 |     const playerId = context.params.path.playerId;
        [error]   34 |     return GameService.turnResults(gameId, turn, playerId);
        [error] > 35 | };
        [error]      | ^
        [error]   36 |     const turn = context.params.path.turn;
        [error]   37 |     const playerId = context.params.path.playerId;
        [error]   38 |     return GameService.turnResults(gameId, turn, playerId);
    parser: |
      (none)

[X] Modify lib/controllers/GameController.ts ✓ https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/64a29d0c5c099e83504418c825b05317c13edee3

Modify lib/controllers/GameController.ts with contents: Remove the repeated declarations of the `turnResults` function and the extra closing brackets `};`. The `turnResults` function should only be declared once and it should take three parameters: `gameId`, `turn`, and `playerId`. These parameters are used to call the `turnResults` function from the `GameService` module. The function should return the result of this call.
[X] Ran sandbox for lib/controllers/GameController.ts. ✓ https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/040d37ddca9039cb55e522c425092d3a81421b0d

Sandbox logs for https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/040d37ddca9039cb55e522c425092d3a81421b0d

trunk fmt lib/controllers/GameController.ts || exit 0 1/2 ✓
 ✔ Formatted lib/controllers/GameController.ts
Re-checking autofixed files...

Checked 1 file
✔ No issues
trunk check --fix --print-failures lib/controllers/GameController.ts 2/2 ✓
Checked 1 file
✔ No issues

[X] Ran sandbox for lib/controllers/GameController.ts. ✓

Sandbox logs for

trunk fmt lib/controllers/GameController.ts || exit 0 1/2 ✓
Checked 1 file
✔ No issues
trunk check --fix --print-failures lib/controllers/GameController.ts 2/2 ✓
Checked 1 file
✔ No issues

[X] Modify lib/service/GameService.ts ✓ https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/8bff271646253f18a32f3b886bba92e206f781cc

Modify lib/service/GameService.ts with contents:
• Modify the service methods called by the controller methods modified in the previous step.
• Implement the logic to check if the operation has already been performed for the given input. If it has, return the same response as the previous request instead of performing the operation again.
[X] Ran sandbox for lib/service/GameService.ts. ✓ https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/76399764a3aa1b542dfb00bb9ac44028c4ecbc47

Sandbox logs for https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/76399764a3aa1b542dfb00bb9ac44028c4ecbc47

trunk fmt lib/service/GameService.ts || exit 0 1/2 ✓
 ✔ Formatted lib/service/GameService.ts
Re-checking autofixed files...

Checked 1 file
✔ No issues
trunk check --fix --print-failures lib/service/GameService.ts 2/2 ✓
Checked 1 file
✔ No issues

[X] Modify README.md ✓ https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/bd6741ac558387d0f063f9d0dae4aabcd43df247

Modify README.md with contents:
• Update the documentation to reflect the changes made to the API endpoints. Explain that all endpoints are now idempotent and describe the mechanism used to achieve this.
[X] Ran sandbox for README.md. ✓ https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/ae2e935a4f21fd08370f76bac12f26be2f852592

Sandbox logs for https://github.com/bmordue/lgm/commit/ae2e935a4f21fd08370f76bac12f26be2f852592

trunk fmt README.md || exit 0 1/2 ✓

 ✔ Formatted README.md
Re-checking autofixed files...

Checked 1 file
✔ No issues

trunk check --fix --print-failures README.md 2/2 ✓

  ISSUES  
README.md:11:0
 11:0  low  Fenced code blocks should have a language specified  markdownlint/MD040
 32:0  low  Multiple top-level headings in the same document     markdownlint/MD025
Checked 1 file
2 existing issues

Step 3: 🔁 Code Review

I have finished reviewing the code for completeness. I did not find errors for sweep/idempotent-endpoints.

🎉 Latest improvements to Sweep:

Sweep now uses the rope library to refactor Python! Check out Large Language Models are Bad at Refactoring Code. To have Sweep refactor your code, try sweep: Refactor <your_file>.py!
Sweep finds and fixes bugs in your code by writing unit tests! Check out Having GPT-4 Iterate on Unit Tests like a Human.

💡 To recreate the pull request edit the issue title or description. To tweak the pull request, leave a comment on the pull request. ^{Join Our Discord}

bmordue / lgm