bnicenboim / bayescogsci

Textbook on Bayesian Data Analysis for Cognitive Science, Nicenboim, Schad, Vasishth
http://bruno.nicenboim.me/bayescogsci/
5 stars 0 forks source link

Please check my back cover text (347 words, limit is 350) #2

Closed vasishth closed 2 weeks ago

vasishth commented 1 month ago

I pushed the following text to the new repo:

This book introduces Bayesian data analysis and Bayesian cognitive modeling to students and researchers in cognitive science (e.g., linguistics, psycholinguistics, psychology, computer science), with a particular focus on modeling data from planned experiments. The book relies on the probabilistic programming language Stan and the front-end R package brms. The main text in the book only assumes that the reader is familiar with the statistical programming language R, and has basic high school exposure to pre-calculus mathematics; the important mathematical constructs needed for the book are introduced in the first chapter, and all the code used is publicly available at https://bruno.nicenboim.me/bayescogsci/.

Through this book, the reader will be able to develop a practical ability to apply Bayesian modeling within their own fields. The book begins with an informal introduction to foundational topics such as probability theory, and univariate and bi-/multivariate discrete and continuous random variables. Then, the application of Bayes' rule for statistical inference is introduced with several simple analytical examples that require no computing software; the main insight here is that the posterior distribution of a parameter is a compromise between the prior and the likelihood functions. The book then gradually builds up the regression framework to hierarchical regression modeling (aka the linear mixed model). Along the way, there is detailed discussion about the topic of prior selection, and developing a well-defined workflow. Later chapters introduce the Stan programming language, and covers advanced topics such as model comparison using Bayes factors and cross-validation for model comparison. The last four chapters focus on implementing hierarchical computational cognitive models within the Stan environment; several practical examples from cognitive psychology and psycholinguistics are provided.

Bruno Nicenboim is an assistant professor in the department of Cognitive Science and Artificial Intelligence at Tilburg University in the Netherlands, working within the area of computational psycholinguistics. Daniel J. Schad is a cognitive psychologists and is professor of Quantitative Methods at the Health and Medical University in Potsdam, Germany. Shravan Vasishth is professor of psycholinguistics at the department of Linguistics at the University of Potsdam, Germany; he is a chartered statistician (Royal Statistical Society, UK).

bnicenboim commented 1 month ago

all the code used is publicly available at https://bruno.nicenboim.me/bayescogsci/.

It sounds as if only the code is there. Can we change it to?

the content of the book including all the code used is publicly available at https://bruno.nicenboim.me/bayescogsci/.

here, maybe "within their own fields of cognitive science"?

Through this book, the reader will be able to develop a practical ability to apply Bayesian modeling within their own fields.

There is model comparison twice:

Later chapters introduce the Stan programming language, and covers advanced topics such as model comparison using Bayes factors and cross-validation for model comparison.

We could include all the advanced topics:

Later chapters introduce the Stan programming language, and covers advanced topics such as measurement error, meta-analysis, and model comparison using Bayes factors and cross-validation.

bnicenboim commented 1 month ago

ahh, sorry, I didn't see the word limit! Then my suggestions are

Through this book, the reader will be able to develop a practical ability to apply Bayesian modeling within cognitive science.

(also agreement attraction error I think with cover)

Later chapters introduce the Stan programming language, and cover advanced topics such as model comparison using Bayes factors and cross-validation.

the content of the book including code is publicly available at https://bruno.nicenboim.me/bayescogsci/.

vasishth commented 1 month ago

here, maybe "within their own fields of cognitive science"?

We already mentioned cognitive science, so I am trying to avoid redundant words due to the word limit. So this change I don't like.

vasishth commented 1 month ago

I made all the other edits that @bnicenboim suggested, but we are six words over the limit now. Maybe that's OK.

bnicenboim commented 1 month ago

this?

The last four chapters focus on implementing hierarchical computational cognitive models within the Stan environment; several practical examples ~from cognitive psychology and psycholinguistics~ are provided.

vasishth commented 1 month ago

I made some edits. We are now at 348 words. We can add two words to get exactly 350.

bnicenboim commented 1 month ago

We can close this, right?

vasishth commented 4 weeks ago

yes ok

vasishth commented 4 weeks ago

I changed a sentence to:

The R Markdown source code that generated the book is publicly available at

We had R Markdown code and ... code

vasishth commented 4 weeks ago

@bnicenboim please close if OK. I made some minor wording changes.

bnicenboim commented 2 weeks ago

I just changed this to put the cognitive models together:

Later chapters introduce the Stan programming language, and cover advanced topics using practical examples: contrast coding, model comparison using Bayes factors and cross-validation, hierarchical models and reparameterization, defining custom distributions, measurement error models and meta-analysis, and finally, some examples of cognitive models: multinomial processing trees, finite mixture models, and accumulator models.

Is it ok?

vasishth commented 2 weeks ago

yes