search

bobranten / Ext4Fsd

Ext4 file system driver for Windows
831 stars 54 forks source link

Native Windows Support #33

Closed ajmeese7 closed 6 months ago

ajmeese7 commented 1 year ago

Hey, I just found this project today and it works perfectly for the use case I was going for! Great work maintaining this, and obviously props to the original creator @matt-wu.

Out of curiosity, do you know why this hasn't been picked up for official native Windows support yet? I know it's a fairly niche use case, but I can't think of any downsides to adding in ext partition support, since the driver already exists and having it picked up formally would allow them to flesh it out as they see fit and maybe solve the few existing problems the community has identified.

If you don't know, I could try reaching out to some friends in the industry to see if they can get a more concrete answer, this just seems like a huge missed opportunity on their part IMO. Cheers!

bobranten commented 1 year ago

Thank you for this report, it is always nice to here from users!

Bo Branten

xAffan commented 8 months ago

Hey, I just found this project today and it works perfectly for the use case I was going for! Great work maintaining this, and obviously props to the original creator @matt-wu.

Out of curiosity, do you know why this hasn't been picked up for official native Windows support yet? I know it's a fairly niche use case, but I can't think of any downsides to adding in ext partition support, since the driver already exists and having it picked up formally would allow them to flesh it out as they see fit and maybe solve the few existing problems the community has identified.

If you don't know, I could try reaching out to some friends in the industry to see if they can get a more concrete answer, this just seems like a huge missed opportunity on their part IMO. Cheers!

Did you get an answer?

ajmeese7 commented 8 months ago

@xAffan no updates on my end

mirh commented 7 months ago

Windows just supports FAT*, NTFS, UDF and (maybe) ReFS. I don't know why you think microsoft would be interested into supporting stuff that isn't "native to their own perspective". (even though they do eventually support ext4 with WSL2)

ajmeese7 commented 7 months ago

@mirh exactly like you said, because Microsoft has pivoted towards Linux support/integration over the last several years, and I anticipate they will continue to do so moving forwards. After acquiring GitHub, the company has taken great steps to support the Open Source community, and I think this is a direction they will remain on as long as the current CEO remains in the chair :)

OLuserGi commented 6 months ago

Hello! I want install my Windows 11 for test into EXT4 base partition or into vDISK.vhdx, which save into EXT4 base partition. I do this:

HDD 120GB = 2 GB FAT16 + 109,6 GB EXT4 base partition; Save vDISK.vhdx 100 GB NTFS to 109,6 GB EXT4 base partition; Save bootmgr.efi into 2 GB FAT16; I need 4) mount EXT4 base partition (driver ext4_x64.efi) over BCD and bootmgr.efi; Mount vDISK.vhdx 100 GB NTFS over BCD and bootmgr.efi; Install Windows to vDISK.vhdx. Now I have work OS Windows 11 on vDISK.vhdx into NTFS base partition. This work. I want use EXT4 base partition.

Can you help me?

mirh commented 6 months ago

Don't you also have to mod winload to be able to load new file system drivers?