search

bocoup / stereotropes-client

12 stars 1 forks source link

Links between some tropes and movies not appearing #184

Open tafsiri opened 9 years ago

tafsiri commented 9 years ago

Here is an issue reported by @incompl. I'll illustrate with an example.

If you go to the film page for frozen and then scroll down to the last female trope in those lists "Winter Royal Lady" and click on that you end up on the page for Winter Royal Lady, but its film list doesn't have Frozen.

Could just be this didn't make it through some filter, but @vlandham do you have an idea what may cause this?

vlandham commented 9 years ago

well, right now we limit the 'movies with this trope' list to just 5. we could make it longer.

On Fri, Apr 3, 2015 at 2:22 PM, Yannick Assogba notifications@github.com wrote:

Assigned #184 https://github.com/bocoup/gendertropes-client/issues/184 to @vlandham https://github.com/vlandham.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/bocoup/gendertropes-client/issues/184#event-273004499 .

tafsiri commented 9 years ago

@vlandham in this example there is only one movie in the related movie list for Winter Royal Lady

vlandham commented 9 years ago

well, its in the data. the similar films for winterroyallady only have the one film...

screen shot 2015-04-17 at 2 46 48 pm

I'll try to checkout that pipeline

vlandham commented 9 years ago

well, its probably because the data is really extracted from tropes that are found in the same movie. so you actually need a related trope to get the movies. this data isn't really representative of the way we display it (as we didn't end up using those 'similar tropes' here).

Might be a little late to change though. I'm not sure if anything else is dependent on this data structure.

code to generate is in src/trope/similar.py in analysis repo.

ajpiano commented 9 years ago

Hey y'all - before I filed a new issue, I wanted to check if something like linking (or the lack thereof) to other tropes on TVtropes (that may or may not be in the stereotropes dataset) like "Take a Level in Badass" on http://stereotropes.bocoup.com/tropes/BadAssMustache is a manifestation of this issue, or something else.

iros commented 9 years ago

@ajpiano, this is definitely an issue we're aware of. We're using TV Tropes data, but through an intermediary called "DB Tropes" which is a linked-data version of tvtropes. They strip all the HTML tags from the trope description. By the time we get it, it's just plain text. It would have been great to have those links there... I think it's worth making another issue, since it is a separate issue technically speaking, and we can track this going forward.

Irene Ros Organizer and Program Chair, OpenVis Conf, http://openvisconf.com Data Visualization Practice Lead, Bocoup, http://bocoup.com/datavis http://bocoup.com | 413-265-3704 | irene@bocoup.com

On Thu, Apr 23, 2015 at 10:35 PM, adam j. sontag notifications@github.com wrote:

Hey y'all - before I filed a new issue, I wanted to check if something like linking (or the lack thereof) to other tropes on TVtropes (that may or may not be in the stereotropes dataset) like "Take a Level in Badass" on http://stereotropes.bocoup.com/tropes/BadAssMustache is a manifestation of this issue, or something else.

https://camo.githubusercontent.com/07b18b18e4cd82b83868075b6c8a0126ebd5820e/68747470733a2f2f636c6475702e636f6d2f4268666f747a365338632d3230303078323030302e706e67

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/bocoup/stereotropes-client/issues/184#issuecomment-95779282 .