search

boostorg / python

Boost.org python module
http://boostorg.github.io/python
Boost Software License 1.0
467 stars 201 forks source link

compilation broken with msvc 14 update 3 #116

Open RiccardoRossi opened 7 years ago

RiccardoRossi commented 7 years ago

Dear Mantainers,

boost.python is currently broken on msvc 14 update 3.

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/38261530/unresolved-external-symbols-since-visual-studio-2015-update-3-boost-python-link

I wanted to know if any workaround was being implemented within new versions of boost to avoid that problem.

SPKorhonen commented 7 years ago

The issue has also been reported to MS. For details please see https://connect.microsoft.com/VisualStudio/feedback/details/2852624/regression-when-building-against-boost-python

RiccardoRossi commented 7 years ago

I was wondering if this was this fixed with the 1.64 or if It is still open. Not easy to test for me since i work un Linux or now on msvc14.1, however oír users have 2015 as a requirement so this is effectively a blocker for us

stefanseefeld commented 7 years ago

I'm not aware of any related change in Boost.Python. This appears to be a MSVC bug, which I have no idea how to work around. (I'm only a very casual Windows user, though I'd be happy to accept a patch, if it can be demonstrated to work around the issue and not introduce any other problems.

RiccardoRossi commented 7 years ago

Dear Stefan, thank you for the answer. Unfortunately i do not have a patch...Noþedit]r a clue of how to Fix It.

However should t the bug be announcef d clearly on the boost documentation? I don t know what the boost policy is in these cases, however It effectively blocks the usage of one of the Major compilers in Windows...

stefanseefeld commented 7 years ago

As long as I don't have a clear understanding of what the bug is (and what combination of compiler & code will trigger it) I'm afraid I wouldn't even know what to announce. Until then we'll have to fall back to simply answer reports here and wait for someone to either submit a workaround or Microsoft to fix their compiler.

RiccardoRossi commented 7 years ago

Hi again, As posted at the beginning of this thread (link https://connect.microsoft.com/VisualStudio/feedback/details/2852624/regression-when-building-against-boost-python) this affects visual studio 2015 update 3, and affectd to my understanding almost any boost.python code. The link also contains a "workaround") which however implies touching all of the boost.python interfaces. It is beyond me to know if the workaround is applicable on the boost side ir if It needs necessary to be on the user side.

It works both on msvc2015 update 2 and visual studio 2017

stefanseefeld commented 7 years ago

The issue you are referring to is marked as "fixed" as of last summer. (And while there is mention of a workaround, I can't see clear instructions as to what needs to happen. I'm certainly not going to change all interfaces for one broken compiler. That's way too invasive.)

garyfurnish commented 7 years ago

I believe this is the same as #148

RiccardoRossi commented 7 years ago

Uff I misunderstood your comment and made a comment in #148

My point is that it used to work with 2017. It would be a huge problem if it breaks again, also on the latest release of msvc 😂

tyanalunas commented 6 years ago

@stefanseefeld If you are still looking for a repro case for this bug, it happens when compiling the python bindings for Alembic (PyAlembic): https://github.com/alembic/alembic

I was able to author a fix for PyAlembic using the strategy mentioned in the above link: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/38261530/unresolved-external-symbols-since-visual-studio-2015-update-3-boost-python-link

Alternatively, I was also able to successfully build by installing the "vanilla" version of msvc14 build tools from 7/19/2015 (not update 3): https://my.visualstudio.com/Downloads?q=build%20tools%202015&wt.mc_id=o~msft~vscom~older-downloads