search

borgbase / vorta

Desktop Backup Client for Borg Backup
https://vorta.borgbase.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.98k stars 130 forks source link

Create a flatpak package for Vorta+BorgBackup #242

Closed thecursedfly closed 5 years ago

thecursedfly commented 5 years ago

Hi,

It would be great if you could package the Vorta GUI together with BorgBackup in a flatpak package (see https://flatpak.org/ for info/documentation). That way me and other non techy users would be able to use this data backup solution on their computer without having to build from source or install separate components. I recommend a flatpak package because it is distribution independent, avoids dependency problems and incompatibilities with older/newer Linux distribution versions, and allows sandboxing for additional security. (I opened the same issue for a similar tool but there is no flatpak yet, so I'm still looking for a flatpacked Borg GUI solution)

Thanks!

m3nu commented 5 years ago

I considered this before for Snapcraft/Snap. In the end we decided to leave packaging to other people. (except for macOS)

We also have an open issue to make fat binaries for Vorta. This is almost done. Just needs building on older systems to be more compatible.

I'll look into it and see how Flatpak compares to a single binary.

Hofer-Julian commented 5 years ago

I am also going to look into flatpaks at some point. I am curious, how many problems will come from sandboxing. I already encountered one problem: https://github.com/flatpak/flatpak-builder-tools/issues/26

m3nu commented 5 years ago

Good point. A backup tool needs to read at the very minimum your own files.

On macOS this is already an issue and users need to grant "Full Disk Access" in privacy settings before being able to backup folders like Contacts and Calendar.

Hofer-Julian commented 5 years ago

Vorta is now packaged as a flatpak and will soon be published at flathub.

ghost commented 4 years ago

I have ethical concerns that I would like to share and discuss with you. Flathub supports proprietary apps, but I only use Free Software. But even if I only install Free Software with Vorta via Flathub, all proprietary packages of Flathub are suddenly displayed. Please support Free Software by offering a direct download of your Flatpak version via your website. Could you imagine this from my argumentation, so that a system with only Free Software and Vorta becomes possible?

m3nu commented 4 years ago

You can already use pip or this repo to get the code directly, if you can't use Flatpak. (I don't use it.)