search

bpmnmatrix / bpmnmatrix.github.io

Comparison of BMPN tools
https://bpmnmatrix.github.io
Other
40 stars 37 forks source link

Add BPSim support column #57

Open EmmanuelGaudin opened 2 years ago

EmmanuelGaudin commented 2 years ago

Hi, The table is minimalistic. Would be interesting to add a few thing such as:

  1. Remove cross-platform and replace it with "web based".
  2. Add a BPSim support column.
  3. Leave an open field for the tool makers to describe a specificity of their tools. Regards, Emmanuel
dialogik commented 1 year ago

Hi, thank you for your comment.

Remove cross-platform and replace it with "web based".

Yes, that is a good idea. I've had this thought already and thought about if there might be differences between cross-platform and web-based and yes, there is. E.g. a Java application is cross-platform but not necessarily web-based. I think I will add a column "web-based" in the future. Feel free to edit the code and data provided in order to speed up this process.

Add a BPSim support column.

What would you suggest to be the possible values this column contains?

Leave an open field for the tool makers to describe a specificity of their tools.

It is a great idea to add a larger text field that can contain description texts by the vendors. I would favor a solution where the additional data is displayed after a click (e.g. by sliding down more information or by a modal popup) in order to keep the table clean.

EmmanuelGaudin commented 1 year ago

Yes, that is a good idea. I've had this thought already and thought about if there might be differences between cross-platform and web-based and yes, there is. E.g. a Java application is cross-platform but not necessarily web-based. I think I will add a column "web-based" in the future. Feel free to edit the code and data provided in order to speed up this process.

I think "cross-platform" is redundant with the different OS columns. Where "web based" is unrelated to the OS. By the way you should remove the "Unix" as this is not relevant any more.

Add a BPSim support column.

What would you suggest to be the possible values this column contains?

BPSim allows to add time and cost information to each BPMN activity. There could be two columns: one for Edit (y/n) and one for Simulate (y/n).

Leave an open field for the tool makers to describe a specificity of their tools.

It is a great idea to add a larger text field that can contain description texts by the vendors. I would favor a solution where the additional data is displayed after a click (e.g. by sliding down more information or by a modal popup) in order to keep the table clean.

As you wish.