Open Daniel-Mietchen opened 6 years ago
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
6 years ago Checking the first one of these reveals that indeed https://www.wikidata.org/w/index.php?title=Q47318649&oldid=619980226#P356 has a statement with a DOI of "234", which can be traced back to both
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
6 years ago For this case, a Crossref search does not yield any immediate results, so not sure where the problem may come from.
Trying another one: https://www.wikidata.org/w/index.php?title=Q47237543&oldid=619205622#P356 has a DOI of "2717", which is stated at both
In this case, a Crossref search yields a DOI of 10.1016/j.joca.2012.02.324, which points to a chain of redirects currently ending at http://www.oarsijournal.com/article/S1063-4584(12)00396-2/fulltext .
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
6 years ago I am focusing right now on removing those erroneous statements from Wikidata. Have done the first batch with the 200 listed above (sample edit).
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
6 years ago The next batch is running (sample edit):
Q47318649 234
Q47622493 275
Q39475431 2404
Q47825282 248
Q40293032 2512
Q36307852 2516
Q38793196 2590
Q38733604 2617
Q47296869 2678
Q50114728 2690
Q47622499 271
Q47237518 2720
Q50064952 2724
Q50065000 2736
Q50045792 2740
Q47581296 2754
Q47616130 2755
Q47226404 2774
Q49557679 2782
Q47713326 287
Q48580830 2370
Q40570392 2422
Q38733618 2613
Q47990127 2671
Q49557873 2762
Q50120903 15237
Q38878556 2292
Q39736348 2327
Q40632882 2357
Q38922655 2382
Q47673009 2416
Q47677084 2428
Q39153127 2641
Q38619588 2655
Q47736218 2656
Q50064976 2732
Q50045794 2739
Q48544958 2743
Q47353601 2751
Q41987594 2699
Q50045763 2753
Q47696762 2763
Q39836601 2297
Q40109040 2310
Q47425515 2316
Q36098487 2386
Q47400163 2410
Q38793199 2589
Q47722197 2624
Q38660792 2632
Q47665127 2658
Q50114800 2676
Q50114758 2686
Q47247223 2694
Q50090649 2698
Q47237530 2718
Q42516106 276
Q47204498 2776
Q40706287 2301
Q40736000 2314
Q40632908 2346
Q47719531 2388
Q39475424 2407
Q39349052 2424
Q48032288 2626
Q47270845 2670
Q47990068 2679
Q47571730 2778
Q40615939 2402
Q33438056 2502
Q47418501 2511
Q40143067 2640
Q46307524 2685
Q40735987 2319
Q50236451 2360
Q40629669 2379
Q39475418 2408
Q38793185 2593
Q47867277 2615
Q42510833 2619
Q50090645 2697
Q47601076 2705
Q50045773 2750
Q50045768 2752
Q42623735 14430
Q39836614 2287
Q38844279 2317
Q47829134 2515
Q47247232 2693
Q47243214 2713
Q47620259 2728
Q50045751 2757
Q49557701 2780
Q41926154 279
Q40099248 2364
Q40615954 2398
Q47326982 2636
Q47294095 2652
Q47825307 2695
Q50064957 2725
Q43827428 005
Q47204504 2771
Q39736373 2320
Q47757765 2347
Q39349045 2425
Q47867247 2622
Q50114784 2680
Q41987591 2704
Q50064971 2731
Q50045775 2749
Q47712460 2352
Q40582887 2371
Q40615962 2395
Q40615928 2414
Q47705190 2639
Q50090678 2711
Q47788094 2312
Q39736353 2325
Q39475452 2399
Q47246545 2506
Q50090655 2701
Q47219034 2741
Q47788040 2326
Q38838463 2575
Q49557775 2772
Q39647503 2362
Q39044311 2492
Q44339130 2530
Q47400452 2389
Q38946283 2433
Q38793192 2591
Q38793176 2596
Q47696342 2683
Q50090662 2706
Q47237486 2722
Q47808580 2332
Q39240341 2569
Q47640967 2677
Q50114734 2689
Q50064965 2730
Q47994072 2436
Q40582868 2376
Q39480271 006
Q50146653 20651
Q47237497 2721
Q39691739 72579
Q47270833 2674
Q47439210 2285
Q45911568 29683
Q39508789 2368
Q40098334 22846
Q40005702 45968
Q30387748 IJIV7I1A5
Q30379840 SMW-12737
Q30393146 010135/AIM.0022
Q30411201 012151/AIM.0015
Q30418574 IJIV9I2A2
Q30833544 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_02_04
Q30947237 1396674/DOT.2009.45.9.1418185
Q31042376 0161902/AIM.009
Q33316768 2008/03/SMW-11717
Q33404058 0121511/AIM.0016
Q33400846 012155/AIM.0011
Q33399553 02.2012/JCPSP.101104
Q33415425 04.2014/JCPSP.340344
Q33408869 07.2013/JCPSP.463467
Q33397189 09.2011/JCPSP.564566
Q33419396 11.2014/JCPSP.S281S283
Q33427615 11.2015/JCPSP.841842
Q33636173 05.2010/JCPSP.307309
Q33611800 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_10_02_07
Q34013845 09.2008/JCPSP.565568
Q34145318 DOI: 10.1097/NUR.0B013E3181ECDC32
Q34158254 JSC.2010.5.1.23
Q34196229 DOI: CVJ-21.023
Q34511182 MAGYONKOL.2012.56.4.230
Q34680776 0172002/AIM.004
Q34647036 04.2013/JCPSP.261264
Q35323368 0141710/AIM.004
Q35643743 CLICA1506859870
Q35643751 CLICA1506877882
Q35688834 DOI:10.11817/J.ISSN.1672-7347.2015.06.008
Q35776801 09.2015/JCPSP.698699
Q37093890 08112/AIM.0012
Q37091854 2008/05/SMW-11958
Q37091857 2008/05/SMW-11964
Q37091860 2008/07/SMW-12045
Q37152946 01.2008/JCPSP.5863
Q37145944 2008/15/SMW-12180
Q37202747 08114/AIM.0016
Q37202666 2008/25/SMW-12231
Q37226592 2008/29/SMW-12311
Q37340247 07.04/IJAAI.195202
Q37366630 SMW-12151
Q37373468 SMW-12246
Q37471582 SMW-12284
Q37635771 1396674/DOT.2009.45.8.1396674
Q37643474 1396674/DOT.2009.45.9.1416421
Q37662416 SMW-12696
Q37666877 SMW-12765
Q37805465 010136/AIM.0017
Q37789577 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_10_03_02
Q37982311 JSC.2010.5.4.155
Q37982315 JSC.2010.5.4.187
Q38020904 012157/AIM.007
Q38000610 04.2012/JCPSP.240245
Q38032388 08.2012/JCPSP.529530
Q37997878 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_12_01_17
Q38038204 012159/AIM.0014
Q38038203 012159/AIM.004
Q38070205 013161/AIM.007
Q38083748 013163/AIM.0011
Q38058174 DOI: 10.3113/FAI.2012.0964
Q38068057 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_12_04_04
Q38068059 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_12_04_06
Q38068064 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_12_04_12
Q38045863 DOI:10.2223/JPED.2218
Q38103888 013165/AIM.0010
Q38103887 013165/AIM.005
Q38131853 013169/AIM.0012
Q38093704 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_13_01_12
Q38101812 JSC.2012.7.3.155
Q38160332 JSC.2013.7.4.229
Q38195349 0141703/AIM.005
Q38195350 0141703/AIM.006
Q38194718 03.2014/JCPSP.182185
Q38201949 JSC.2014.8.2.115
Q38201956 JSC.2014.8.3/4.151
Q38252358 08.2014/JCPSP.676684
Q38213576 110.1097/QAD.0000000000000230
Q38227884 doi:10.1142/S0129065789000499
Q38243379 JSC.2014.9.1.1
Q38243388 JSC.2014.9.2.117
Q38243341 JSC.2014.9.3.199
Q38314340 0.1016/0378-1119(93)90373-B
Q38264572 0141711/AIM.009
Q38284115 0141712/AIM.007
Q38325586 01.2015/JCPSP.6067
Q38341638 015182/AIM.0013
Q38385477 DOI:10.11817/J.ISSN.1672-7347.2015.10.007
Q38417197 05.2014/JCPSP.S84S85
Q38496284 011141/AIM.004
Q38496110 03.2009/JCPSP.186188
Q38544815 0151807/AIM.004
Q38534960 06.2015/JCPSP.443448
Q38600886 0151810/AIM.007
Q38626496 SMW.2017.14481
Q38684769 SMW.2017.14444
Q38718318 IJIV14I2A5
Q38738900 NO_DOI/1496776443087
Q38743576 IJIV13I3A3
Q47567044 NO_DOI
Q38794884 SMW.2017.14433
Q38825275 JSC.2015.10.4.287
Q38831088 SMW.2017.14422
Q38862973 0161906/AIM.0012
Q38863257 0161909/AIM.005
Q38865083 05.2012/JCPSP.320322
Q38886400 0161904/AIM.003
Q38952282 IJIV11I3A3
Q38965085 IJIV13I3A1
Q38971858 012.01/IJAAI.2936
Q39005170 014174/AIM.0010
Q39005803 0172001/AIM.003
Q39005801 0172001/AIM.005
Q38981498 07.2015/JCPSP.482485
Q38971927 DOI 10.2310/7290.2014.00022
Q39012640 SMW.2016.14376
Q39012644 SMW.2016.14381
Q39012635 SMW.2016.14394
Q39027784 02.2014/JCPSP.9196
Q39044520 04.2015/JCPSP.S14S16
Q39038779 IJIV10I4A7
Q39133240 IJIV10I2A5
Q39155451 07.2014/JCPSP.477480
Q39203271 CLICA
Q39220687 IJIV9I4A1
Q39268793 09.2014/JCPSP.670675
Q39343897 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_13_03_05
Q39348702 IJIV13I3A7
Q39378100 IJIV9I1A1
Q39470655 0161908/AIM.006
Q39533699 010.02/IJAAI.9199
Q39643023 0161907/AIM.004
Q39643017 0161907/AIM.006
Q39655540 02.2012/JCPSP.105107
Q39660916 09.2010/JCPSP.618619
Q39691976 011146/AIM.006
Q39734688 07.2011/JCPSP.360361
Q39777830 010.01/IJAAI.3540
Q39798245 011141/AIM.009
Q39836315 08112/AIM.0017
Q39817044 11.2010/JCPSP.763765
Q39840476 2008/11/SMW-12077
Q39918708 01.2010/JCPSP.6870
Q39866623 0161904/AIM.005
Q39882837 04.2010/JCPSP.262265
Q39877997 IJIV6I1A6
Q39908330 SMW-12805
Q39958893 11.2010/JCPSP.753756
Q39958897 11.2010/JCPSP.760762
Q39938582 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_10_02_04
Q39951320 IJIV3I3A4
Q39927884 SMW-12756
Q39977333 04.2011/JCPSP.223226
Q40030413 0161902/AIM.006
Q39997576 02.2016/JCPSP.108112
Q39997558 02.2016/JCPSP.130133
Q40029413 04.2012/JCPSP.230234
Q40007113 11.2011/JCPSP.676679
Q40029991 DOI:10.2223/JPED.2173
Q40069943 09.04/IJAAI.207217
Q40086381 01.2016/JCPSP.2730
Q40116279 0161903/AIM.0013
Q40114073 03.2016/JCPSP.187190
Q40111053 05.2013/JCPSP.314318
Q40116806 SMW.2017.14469
Q40157754 04.2015/JCPSP.S8S9
Q40154644 05.2015/JCPSP.376377
Q40161598 IJIV12I4A8
Q40127870 SMW.2017.14467
Q40165183 0141701/AIM.003
Q40172731 0161901/AIM.004
Q40172725 0161901/AIM.006
Q40183527 03.2014/JCPSP.S55S56
Q40184419 12.2015/JCPSP.878881
Q40219024 02.2014/JCPSP.141142
Q40209577 07.2014/JCPSP.503507
Q40230138 11.2013/JCPSP.826827
Q40241014 0172004/AIM.006
Q40268406 11.2012/JCPSP.737739
Q40244751 12.2014/JCPSP.931934
Q40274197 IJIV14I1A8
Q40287017 015186/AIM.0014
Q40291017 04.2012/JCPSP.252254
Q40312210 09.2011/JCPSP.539541
Q40316321 CLICA110812011208
Q40283391 SMW.2017.14407
Q40331283 11.2015/JCPSP.811814
Q40402308 0161912/AIM.0011
Q40368629 0172001/AIM.0010
Q40361345 04.2010/JCPSP.258261
Q40382544 08.02/IJAAI.117119
Q40383204 08.2009/JCPSP.487491
Q40383199 08.2009/JCPSP.518519
Q40383193 08.2009/JCPSP.531533
Q40380803 09.2009/JCPSP.591594
Q40407744 CLICA17013943
Q40535678 09.2015/JCPSP.640643
Q40609594 08.2015/JCPSP.560563
Q40609586 08.2015/JCPSP.573578
Q40680979 CLICA160710031008
Q40699357 07.2015/JCPSP.495497
Q40699344 07.2015/JCPSP.510513
Q40809910 06.2015/JCPSP.399402
Q40809896 06.2015/JCPSP.431433
Q40858054 0161901/AIM.0011
Q40862308 12.2015/JCPSP.867869
Q40904406 05.2015/JCPSP.350353
Q40904399 05.2015/JCPSP.363366
Q40978175 IJIV12I3A4
Q40975423 JSC.2015.9.4.219
Q41056237 DOI:10.11817/J.ISSN.1672-7347.2015.07.004
Q41117738 11.2015/JCPSP.794797
Q41172764 015186/AIM.004
Q41372245 JSC.2010.4.4.191
Q41418329 IJIV12I1A3
Q41470804 02.2015/JCPSP.104107
Q41470798 02.2015/JCPSP.108110
Q41554996 01.2015/JCPSP.2226
Q41565082 0151801/AIM.009
Q41570966 IJIV11I4A1
Q41570959 IJIV11I4A7
Q41597496 0151807/AIM.0010
Q41593958 11.2014/JCPSP.S196S197
Q41593946 11.2014/JCPSP.S211S213
Q41592417 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_04_13
Q41672881 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_04_06
Q41672874 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_04_07
Q41679688 0141711/AIM.008
Q41746132 0141709/AIM.006
Q41718922 05.2015/JCPSP.324327
Q41984124 12.2010/JCPSP.837838
Q42166469 /S0034-98872010000200005
Q42166479 /S0034-98872010000200007
Q42166525 /S0034-98872010000200013
Q42225754 03.2014/JCPSP.S50S51
Q42210768 06.2014/JCPSP.408411
Q42251146 12.2013/JCPSP.833836
Q42268492 DOI:10.7416/AI.2013.1944
Q42280841 013161/AIM.0012
Q42443694 /S0716-97602008000200011
Q42486128 04.2011/JCPSP.254256
Q42668709 07.2010/JCPSP.492493
Q42756478 /S0034-98872010000900004
Q42756458 /S0034-98872010000900013
Q42756455 /S0034-98872010000900015
Q42756446 /S0034-98872010000900018
Q42753752 /S0034-98872010001100006
Q42753750 /S0034-98872010001100007
Q42753742 /S0034-98872010001100010
Q42753812 /S0034-98872010001200005
Q42753798 /S0034-98872010001200010
Q42741550 /S0034-98872010001300005
Q42741548 /S0034-98872010001300006
Q42741527 /S0034-98872010001300016
Q42753718 /S0716-10182010000700005
Q42756436 /S0716-97602010000300008
Q42770839 IJIV7I4A2
Q42856593 09.03/IJAAI.169173
Q26779772 0151811/AIM.0010
Q28085072 0151812/AIM.0011
Q29310691 DOI:10.1016/S0378-8741(03)00007-2
Q30235962 0172002/AIM.0011
Q30491436 SMW.2017.14423
Q30719178 MAGYONKOL.2013.57.4.240
Q30875172 0141712/AIM.008
Q33168872 SMW.2017.14462
Q33275071 MAGYONKOL.2013.57.4.269
Q33395100 011143/AIM.0010
Q33397889 011146/AIM.009
Q33379922 05.2008/JCPSP.282285
Q33381069 07.03/IJAAI.169175
Q33392331 09.03/IJAAI.181183
Q33358353 IJIV3I4A2
Q33419879 01.2015/JCPSP.3134
Q33420618 02.2015/JCPSP.119123
Q33521394 12.2009/JCPSP.796797
Q33611806 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_10_02_10
Q33747173 04.2010/JCPSP.738743
Q33917992 CLICA1106871877
Q34026701 011143/AIM.0018
Q34023998 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_10_03_10
Q34223746 04.2012/JCPSP.267268
Q34347855 013166/AIM.0010
Q34624902 010136/AIM.008
Q34614057 1396673/DOT.2009.45.8.1396673
Q34776281 03.2008/JCPSP.190192
Q34779825 2008/19/SMW-11971
Q35000535 CLICA090913191319
Q34981745 SMW-12342
Q35071824 MAGYONKOL.2013.57.4.232
Q35577765 0151803/AIM.004
Q35725383 CLICA150811751181
Q35776797 09.2015/JCPSP.654657
Q36294427 CVJ-21.016
Q36334388 JSC.2009.4.1.29
Q36524349 I 10.12788/JCSO.0058
Q36726673 0.1016/0378-1119(94)90167-8
Q37041443 CVJ-21.074
Q37073363 CVJ-21.008
Q37102033 IJIV5I1A1
Q37117703 2008/11/SMW-10387
Q37186839 05.2008/JCPSP.321322
Q37293933 /AOP/SMW-AOP12276
Q37308163 /AOP/SMW-AOP12283
Q37355497 IJIV5I4A1
Q37389069 SMW-12447
Q37377688 SMW-12468
Q37398719 SMW-12166
Q37487740 SMW-12365
Q37487749 SMW-12465
Q37634033 SMW-12517
Q37617193 SMW-12528
Q37643471 1396674/DOT.2009.45.9.1414786
Q37635774 1396675/DOT.2009.45.8.1396675
Q37641887 SMW-12707
Q37672997 1396674/DOT.2009.45.10.1427441
Q37748623 SMW-12995
Q37816083 09.04/IJAAI.191206
Q37856610 0.4415/ANN_11_01_05
Q37849271 012153/AIM.0013
Q37906230 DOI: 10.1227/NEU.0B013E318218C78F
Q37975086 01.2012/JCPSP.6668
Q37972321 012151/AIM.0012
Q37970965 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_11_04_06
Q37970967 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_11_04_07
Q37970970 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_11_04_12
Q38023828 011.02/IJAAI.89109
Q38020905 012157/AIM.0013
Q38029134 012158/AIM.008
Q38005866 05.2012/JCPSP.311316
Q38005867 05.2012/JCPSP.335337
Q38071365 01.2013/JCPSP.9798
Q38068058 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_12_04_05
Q38068061 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_12_04_08
Q38125818 0013168/AIM.004
Q38110914 013166/AIM.009
Q38117670 013167/AIM.0010
Q38160944 0131611/AIM.0010
Q38170452 0131612/AIM.007
Q38168640 12.2013/JCPSP.878884
Q38203910 014174/AIM.0012
Q38223516 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_02_07
Q38293866 12.2014/JCPSP.935939
Q38257829 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_03_09
Q38293149 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_04_03
Q38243386 JSC.2014.9.2.93
Q38243339 JSC.2014.9.3.127
Q38306410 0151801/AIM.0012Some of those — e.g. those with DOIs of the form "DOI: 10.4415/ANN_11_04_06" (cf. Q37970965) — look like a simple fix, which I will look into later.
I am beginning to think, though, that the best way forward may actually be to keep the wrong DOI statements in Wikidata and to deprecate them there. Given that two reputable sources agree on the values, however, claiming such deprecation would require a reference that attests to the erroneousness of these DOI values, which does not yet exist outside this ticket and the DOI Handbook.
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
6 years ago The next batch of 400 (the Wikidata query times out for 500 now, and offsets to get beyond 400 don't work for me either right now):
Q38341640 015182/AIM.0017
Q38405721 015184/AIM.009
Q38456105 CLICA121218711878
Q38459734 JSC.2015.9.4.269
Q38553664 07.2015/JCPSP.519524
Q38587640 09.2015/JCPSP.680688
Q38594233 IJIV12I1A1
Q38675783 :10.1922/CDH_4073SONODA04
Q38660509 0172007/AIM.005
Q38660505 0172007/AIM.006
Q38672621 SMW.2017.14445
Q38710855 0172006/AIM.0010
Q38716190 SMW.2017.14437
Q38684771 SMW.2017.14463
Q38729951 0172004/AIM.003
Q38742443 SMW.2017.14418
Q38742448 SMW.2017.14419
Q38797328 0161904/AIM.0012
Q38770959 0161905/AIM.007
Q38834414 0161905/AIM.0011
Q38834417 0161905/AIM.0012
Q38847771 IJIV13I2A5
Q38877014 0151805/AIM.006
Q38891421 SMW.2017.14409
Q38891407 SMW.2017.14416
Q38891412 SMW.2017.14420
Q38950290 0151811/AIM.0013
Q39133244 IJIV10I2A4
Q39169338 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_02_03
Q39204713 0141707/AIM.003
Q39205812 05.2014/JCPSP.S115S116
Q39218475 NO_DOI/1491233844057
Q39233111 0141703/AIM.007
Q39247331 06.2012/JCPSP.349352
Q39236678 12.2012/JCPSP.778782
Q39302844 06.2009/JCPSP.350353
Q39294783 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_12_02_05
Q39294970 SMW.2017.14428
Q39320265 011.02/IJAAI.121132
Q39349354 JSC.2010.5.3.117
Q39387497 0161909/AIM.0011
Q39394134 IJIV10I2A1
Q39427773 SMW.2017.14447
Q39470650 0161908/AIM.007
Q39836309 08112/AIM.0016
Q39845417 03.2008/JCPSP.147150
Q39881526 08.04/IJAAI.205210
Q39843718 08113/AIM.0015
Q39921249 03.2016/JCPSP.173176
Q39921241 03.2016/JCPSP.195198
Q39918152 SMW-12927
Q39920753 SMW-12975
Q39962050 0161903/AIM.003
Q39944626 04.2010/JCPSP.533537
Q39988927 07.2011/JCPSP.325329
Q39991490 SMW-12381
Q40026120 02.2012/JCPSP.163167
Q39997565 02.2016/JCPSP.125129
Q40005897 IJIV5I1A3
Q40004005 SMW-12489
Q40045208 07.2012/JCPSP.455457
Q40047171 2008/35/SMW-12108
Q40053227 DOI:10.2223/JPED.2193
Q40065178 DOI:10.2223/JPED.2211
Q40067013 SMW.2017.14497
Q40086363 01.2016/JCPSP.3640
Q40086347 01.2016/JCPSP.7475
Q40095440 012.01/IJAAI.5762
Q40077774 0121512/AIM.004
Q40095033 03.2008/JCPSP.137141
Q40095027 03.2008/JCPSP.158162
Q40141440 0131610/AIM.007
Q40141500 0151809/AIM.0013
Q40129316 CLICA151218011807
Q40183041 04.2014/JCPSP.256260
Q40157779 04.2015/JCPSP.S17S18
Q40184432 12.2015/JCPSP.863866
Q40184409 12.2015/JCPSP.911913
Q40221030 0141709/AIM.0010
Q40199489 0172005/AIM.0012
Q40199485 0172005/AIM.0013
Q40230145 11.2013/JCPSP.815817
Q40226081 12.2013/JCPSP.902903
Q40229557 CLICA1705699706
Q40244574 06.2013/JCPSP.437439
Q40274203 IJIV14I1A2
Q40278947 IJIV14I1A4
Q40283400 SMW.2017.14411
Q40319648 0011144/AIM.0016
Q40326608 011143/AIM.0015
Q40309032 0151809/AIM.004
Q40304600 015188/AIM.009
Q40329161 04.2011/JCPSP.219222
Q40345721 01.2016/JCPSP.2326
Q40368637 0172001/AIM.008
Q40353463 06.2010/JCPSP.386390
Q40380809 09.2009/JCPSP.566569
Q40404018 12.2008/JCPSP.740743
Q40459510 0151810/AIM.009
Q40493634 IJIV12I3A3
Q40535657 09.2015/JCPSP.675679
Q40636043 CLICA160710391045
Q40634304 IJIV13I2A6
Q40705423 0161906/AIM.003
Q40699369 07.2015/JCPSP.478481
Q40699352 07.2015/JCPSP.498500
Q40788947 IJIV12I2A1
Q40862977 0.1038/35019592
Q40853098 015186/AIM.005
Q40854304 03.2016/JCPSP.230231
Q40862298 12.2015/JCPSP.909910
Q40889305 0151812/AIM.008
Q40936340 CLICA151116531658
Q41033309 04.2015/JCPSP.259263
Q41117726 11.2015/JCPSP.815818
Q41113314 DOI:10.11817/J.ISSN.1672-7347.2015.06.018
Q41135696 IJIV12I2A3
Q41183271 CLICA151116811688
Q41218474 03.2015/JCPSP.202205
Q41300492 04.2015/JCPSP.247249
Q41454366 08.2015/JCPSP.602605
Q41554987 01.2015/JCPSP.2730
Q41597502 0151807/AIM.006
Q41592443 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_04_09
Q41648780 CLICA141217711778
Q41670411 12.2014/JCPSP.902907
Q41670404 12.2014/JCPSP.908913
Q41705293 0141710/AIM.0015
Q41734271 09.2014/JCPSP.624627
Q41734250 09.2014/JCPSP.695697
Q41712315 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_03_12
Q41916657 0151810/AIM.0013
Q41955233 0.1017/DMP.2015.51
Q41964708 0141701/AIM.0010
Q41940956 04.2008/JCPSP.257258
Q41938760 08.2008/JCPSP.520521
Q41935815 IJIV14I3A1
Q42144693 04.2015/JCPSP.S33S35
Q42166476 /S0034-98872010000200006
Q42164093 08113/AIM.0010
Q42164126 08113/AIM.0017
Q42232233 0141701/AIM.0012
Q42237012 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_13_04_12
Q42246301 IJIV10I4A6
Q42231217 IJIV11I1A1
Q42264833 0131610/AIM.0015
Q42273853 013163/AIM.0015
Q42269040 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_13_01_09
Q42266525 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_13_03_09
Q42288883 0121511/AIM.0014
Q42638575 11.2009/JCPSP.744746
Q42655918 02.2010/JCPSP.106111
Q42652117 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_01_05
Q42741557 /S0034-98872010001300002
Q42741546 /S0034-98872010001300007
Q42741567 /S0716-97602010000400003
Q42753740 /S0034-98872010001100011
Q42753738 /S0034-98872010001100012
Q42753734 /S0034-98872010001100013
Q42753731 /S0034-98872010001100015
Q42753821 /S0034-98872010001200002
Q42753810 /S0034-98872010001200006
Q42753795 /S0034-98872010001200011
Q42753784 /S0034-98872010001200015
Q42753781 /S0034-98872010001200016
Q42753769 /S0034-98872010001200020
Q42756486 /S0034-98872010000900002
Q42756461 /S0034-98872010000900012
Q42783028 /S0034-98872010000800006
Q42783023 /S0034-98872010000800008
Q42783016 /S0034-98872010000800012
Q42782996 /S0034-98872010000800020
Q42782992 /S0034-98872010000800021
Q42778827 /S0716-97602010000100002
Q42778818 /S0716-97602010000100013
Q42769475 011141/AIM.008
Q42762066 12.2010/JCPSP.802805
Q42762062 12.2010/JCPSP.822824
Q42788286 CLICA101218071813
Q42788281 CLICA101218201827
Q42843964 /S0716-97602010000200001
Q42840600 010136/AIM.0020
Q26999319 013161/AIM.0014
Q28843411 DOI:10.1006/KNAC.1993.1008
Q30061902 0161911/AIM.0011
Q30379614 IJIV12I3A5
Q30382601 SMW-12952
Q30395614 TUFFC.2015.007202
Q30852031 15.13155/NCOMMS11317
Q31063185 CLICA1604573578
Q33165886 06.2015/JCPSP.403406
Q33160444 09.2011/JCPSP.572573
Q33158024 11.2009/JCPSP.686689
Q33321013 08112/AIM.004
Q33345778 DOI:10.1017/S1740925X04000110
Q33406200 012.01/IJAAI.5056
Q33414481 04.2014/JCPSP.285287
Q33378858 IJIV5I1A7
Q33418515 0141711/AIM.0016
Q33420137 015182/AIM.0010
Q33419390 11.2014/JCPSP.S216S218
Q33456963 013162/AIM.006
Q33478092 07.2009/JCPSP.440443
Q33492701 08.02/IJAAI.7784
Q34118412 JSC.2012.7.3.181
Q34336803 04.2013/JCPSP.293294
Q34431011 014178/AIM.0013
Q34458542 0121511/AIM.0010
Q34479994 015186/AIM.0016
Q34696158 DOI 10.2310/7290.2014.00020
Q34775727 02.2008/JCPSP.7881
Q35790023 CLICA151015051511
Q35804458 012151/AIM.007
Q35856377 0151812/AIM.0010
Q35938904 0161903/AIM.008
Q36355758 CLICA1705715721
Q37057971 2007/49/SMW-11986
Q37041811 CVJ-21.001
Q37041794 CVJ-21.007
Q37073300 CVJ-21.004
Q37077532 CVJ-21.006
Q37073346 CVJ-21.015
Q37222381 2008/27/SMW-12153
Q37438707 04.2009/JCPSP.223227
Q37520755 SMW-12476
Q37520751 SMW-12584
Q37560786 SMW-12270
Q37634034 SMW-12667
Q37634037 SMW-12742
Q37666883 SMW-12661
Q37641882 SMW-12741
Q37673071 SMW-12953
Q37766732 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_10_02_03
Q37760429 JSC.2009.4.1.57
Q37734974 SMW-12977
Q37824845 011141/AIM.0010
Q37789578 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_10_03_09
Q37848397 011142/AIM.0019
Q37855216 04.2009/JCPSP.228231
Q37853832 12.2009/JCPSP.772775
Q37857914 IJIV5I1A5
Q37906207 DOI: 10.1227/NEU.0B013E31820A19FC
Q37994665 011.01/IJAAI.113
Q37980188 012152/AIM.007
Q37970968 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_11_04_08
Q37982314 JSC.2010.5.4.177
Q38023829 011.02/IJAAI.111119
Q38040592 011.03/IJAAI.203216
Q38055881 0121511/AIM.0013
Q38029135 012158/AIM.0010
Q38059327 11.2012/JCPSP.711715
Q38058175 DOI: 10.3113/FAI.2012.0969
Q38058176 DOI: 10.3113/FAI.2012.1031
Q38071363 01.2013/JCPSP.7782
Q38071364 01.2013/JCPSP.8385
Q38063388 TA.0B013E3182754654
Q38085985 012.01/IJAAI.117
Q38077599 013162/AIM.0013
Q38083749 013163/AIM.0012
Q38111584 DOI: 10.4244/EIJV9SRA10
Q38114798 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_13_02_14
Q38137318 09.2013/JCPSP.653656
Q38166398 DOI: 10.11607/JOMI.TE29
Q38160333 JSC.2013.7.4.245
Q38177438 01.2014/JCPSP.6061
Q38195352 0141703/AIM.0013
Q38195348 0141703/AIM.004
Q38201612 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_14_01_12
Q38201957 JSC.2014.8.3/4.189
Q38232878 07.2014/JCPSP.508514
Q38243387 JSC.2014.9.2.107
Q38325580 01.2015/JCPSP.4145
Q38390194 0141709/AIM.0011
Q38405735 015184/AIM.0012
Q38378874 03.2015/JCPSP.210215
Q38410646 0161901/AIM.0010
Q38477899 014174/AIM.009
Q38522485 015186/AIM.0011
Q38678879 0161901/AIM.0012
Q38675664 12.2015/JCPSP.891896
Q38657235 SMW.2017.14470
Q38703419 01.2016/JCPSP.5159
Q38684775 SMW.2017.14474
Q38722765 NO_DOI/1497537194790
Q38764868 0161906/AIM.009
Q38782854 0172005/AIM.0010
Q38782867 0172005/AIM.003
Q38794891 SMW.2017.14429
Q38901613 011.03/IJAAI.253258
Q38891013 015184/AIM.006
Q38911422 0172003/AIM.0012
Q38911432 0172003/AIM.005
Q38911428 0172003/AIM.008
Q38878936 JSC.2015.9.4.243
Q38887828 NO_DOI/1490108138367
Q38924453 JSC.2015.10.4.217
Q38997521 015186/AIM.006
Q38971948 DOI 10.2310/7290.2014.00021
Q38976978 SMW.2017.14401
Q39080326 IJIV13I4A7
Q39194806 01.2016/JCPSP.6062
Q39201616 03.2013/JCPSP.234236
Q39213874 01.2014/JCPSP.4346
Q39212358 02.2016/JCPSP.156157
Q39222397 08.2013/JCPSP.533537
Q39245733 11.2012/JCPSP.690693
Q39215294 MAGYONKOL.2013.57.4.275
Q39320259 011.02/IJAAI.165173
Q39311076 07.04/IJAAI.221229
Q39291760 08.03/IJAAI.165168
Q39311986 2008/43/SMW-12288
Q39348707 IJIV13I3A6
Q39427785 SMW.2017.14440
Q39452256 015188/AIM.0017
Q39455973 IJIV10I1A7
Q39618427 0151805/AIM.0014
Q39687758 11.2011/JCPSP.662665
Q39766504 0161905/AIM.004
Q39803971 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_10_04_01
Q39845141 02.2008/JCPSP.9597
Q39836318 08112/AIM.0018
Q39879550 IJIV13I1A1
Q39871689 IJIV6I1A3
Q39897126 SMW-12607
Q39938102 2008/37/SMW-12385
Q39939923 IJIV5I3A3
Q39903205 IJIV5I4A3
Q39948512 010135/AIM.005
Q39962033 0161903/AIM.007
Q39997582 02.2016/JCPSP.9195
Q39983128 05.2009/JCPSP.287290
Q39963481 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_10_04_03
Q39967340 IJIV6I2A3
Q40018752 012152/AIM.0010
Q40031386 012155/AIM.007
Q40030394 0161902/AIM.0011
Q40058082 SMW.2017.14472
Q40084326 SMW.2017.14482
Q40114066 03.2016/JCPSP.223224
Q40147102 0172006/AIM.004
Q40147078 0172006/AIM.009
Q40157770 04.2015/JCPSP.S20S21
Q40157763 04.2015/JCPSP.S30S32
Q40157540 DOI: 10.4415/ANN_13_04_04
Q40153603 IJIV14I2A6
Q40199395 07.2014/JCPSP.472476
Q40184435 12.2015/JCPSP.860862
Q40232432 0141711/AIM.006
Q40219029 02.2014/JCPSP.114117
Q40210953 03.2014/JCPSP.S20S21
Q40274489 04.2015/JCPSP.276280
Q40247831 05.2013/JCPSP.359361
Q40265315 12.2012/JCPSP.803805
Q40244757 12.2014/JCPSP.940943
Q40320284 07.2011/JCPSP.369370
Q40301420 DOI:10.5152/TPD.2011.59
Q40312037 MAGYONKOL.2011.55.3.155
Q40334773 0172002/AIM.006
Q40349644 09.2010/JCPSP.581585
Q40362009 0172001/AIM.0013
Q40388125 06.2009/JCPSP.393394
Q40420132 01.2008/JCPSP.3739
Q40415641 0161912/AIM.006
Q40419797 03.2008/JCPSP.163167
Q40419164 2008/17/SMW-12051
Q40407740 CLICA1701117123
Q40459519 0151810/AIM.004
Q40493629 IJIV12I3A6
Q40568880 0161908/AIM.0014
Q40613986 0161908/AIM.0010
Q40609559 08.2015/JCPSP.625626
Q40674744 0161905/AIM.0010
Q40674739 0161905/AIM.0013
Q40699362 07.2015/JCPSP.486490
Q40680985 CLICA1607973979
Q40751373 0151807/AIM.007
Q40904393 05.2015/JCPSP.386388
Q40919757 0037-8682-0004-2015
Q40997671 09.2015/JCPSP.671674
Q41215948 0151803/AIM.005
Q41218490 03.2015/JCPSP.176180
Q41218458 03.2015/JCPSP.223224
Q41431510 010136/AIM.0022
Q41470813 02.2015/JCPSP.100103
Q41454375 08.2015/JCPSP.588591
Q41463562 CLICA1503359365
Q41565075 0151801/AIM.0015
Q41591390 12.2014/JCPSP.914917
Q41629123 0151801/AIM.0010
Q41657817 11.2014/JCPSP.840844
Q41718907 05.2015/JCPSP.354358
Q41918472 02.2015/JCPSP.129133
Q41929900 0141707/AIM.0014
Q41930630 0172005/AIM.0014
Q42003021 2008/19/SMW-12056
Q42166443 /S0034-98872010000200002
Q42166458 /S0034-98872010000200004
Q42166548 /S0034-98872010000200016
Q42164111 08113/AIM.0014
Q42210773 06.2014/JCPSP.392395Those 400 are now fixed as well (sample edit).
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
6 years ago The next 50 (everything larger times out):
Q42249720 013169/AIM.007
Q42239424 02.2014/JCPSP.97100
Q42256978 IJIV10I2A6
Q42437714 JSC.2012.7.3.127
Q42475117 SMW-12718
Q42510065 012158/AIM.0016
Q42644893 012155/AIM.0012
Q42722644 012151/AIM.009
Q42783032 /S0034-98872010000800004
Q42783030 /S0034-98872010000800005
Q42783014 /S0034-98872010000800013
Q42783005 /S0034-98872010000800016
Q42783002 /S0034-98872010000800017
Q42753760 /S0034-98872010001100003
Q42753722 /S0034-98872010001100018
Q42753805 /S0034-98872010001200008
Q42753802 /S0034-98872010001200009
Q42753792 /S0034-98872010001200012
Q42753776 /S0034-98872010001200018
Q42753773 /S0034-98872010001200019
Q42741531 /S0034-98872010001300014
Q42741526 /S0034-98872010001300017
Q42756443 /S0716-97602010000300005
Q42741559 /S0716-97602010000400011
Q42762067 12.2010/JCPSP.794797
Q42813472 04.2010/JCPSP.748752
Q42843955 /S0716-97602010000200007
Q42841266 CLICA101117111717
Q26991595 0141712/AIM.009
Q28870154 DOI:10.1080/03115518308619633
Q29042780 DOI:10.7925/DRS1.UCDLIB_45928
Q30248376 0161908/AIM.0012
Q30235309 0172003/AIM.0011
Q30371741 07.2008/JCPSP.445450
Q30414367 012154/AIM.0014
Q30399859 02.2011/JCPSP.97102
Q33160770 12.2011/JCPSP.769771
Q33331609 02.2008/JCPSP.102104
Q33380977 06.2008/JCPSP.362368
Q33368033 07.03/IJAAI.115131
Q33369489 2008/35/SMW-12273
Q33433002 0161906/AIM.0010
Q33400236 02.2012/JCPSP.192193
Q33428354 04.2009/JCPSP.219222
Q33419394 11.2014/JCPSP.S253S255
Q33427612 11.2015/JCPSP.802806
Q33527773 CLICA1002268272
Q33511273 SMW-12767
Q33650452 04.2010/JCPSP.524527
Q33644679 SMW-12768Those 50 are fixed too (sample edit).
fnielsen
commented
6 years ago Would it be better to deprecate rather than delete?
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
6 years ago @fnielsen Yes, deprecation seems to be better, but we need to annotate the deprecation properly (see my comment above), so I think it's OK to remove it for now, but we should eventually put it back in as deprecated, ideally along with whatever valid DOIs these articles actually do have.
Meanwhile, I checked the Wikidata query again, and while it timed out in the Wikidata Query Service, it ran through in the Linked Data Fragments).%0A%20%20%7D) endpoint, giving 0 results as of now.
Actually, re-running it with a limit 1 still yields a result (Q33810881), which I'm thus using to play around with how to indicate the deprecation.
This query gives a list of reasons used in "reason for deprecation" (P2241) statements:
SELECT DISTINCT ?reason ?reasonLabel WHERE {
?statement pq:P2241 ?reason.
SERVICE wikibase:label { bd:serviceParam wikibase:language "[AUTO_LANGUAGE],en". }
}Of these, error (Q29485) seemed the most plausible, so I used that on Q33810881.
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
6 years ago I went randomly through some more entries in the list and have not found any case yet where the PMC/ PubMed entries were correct.
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
6 years ago Summary of today's batch edits, as per https://tools.wmflabs.org/quickstatements/#mode=batches :
2180 | Daniel Mietchen | More odd DOIs, as per https://github.com/br2s/bug-reports-to-science/issues/8 | DONE DONE:50 | 2018-03-13 12:01:19 |
2179 | Daniel Mietchen | More odd DOIs, as per https://github.com/br2s/bug-reports-to-science/issues/8 | DONE DONE:400 | 2018-03-13 11:39:42 |
2178 | Daniel Mietchen | More odd DOIs, as per https://github.com/br2s/bug-reports-to-science/issues/8 | DONE DONE:500 | 2018-03-13 11:16:10 |
2177 | Daniel Mietchen | next try | DONE DONE:199 \| RUN:1 | 2018-03-13 10:26:18 |
2176 | Daniel Mietchen | remove incorrect DOI statements | DONE ERROR:200 | 2018-03-13 10:20:33
Update: LDF).%0A%20%20%7D) just found 16 new cases, all from items that had been started after the above cleanup.
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
5 years ago For a related discussion, see https://twitter.com/27point7/status/1070818580789383168 .
Current counts
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
4 years ago I just checked the example from https://github.com/br2s/bug-reports-to-science/issues/8#issuecomment-372624264 again, i.e. a DOI of "2717", which is still stated at both
Interestingly, the new PubMed interface at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28302227 does not show the invalid DOI any more.
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
2 years ago Update: I just checked for that sample DOI "2717" again, and while it is still there at PubMed, it is not in Europe PMC any more.
I also came across a publisher's report about wrong DOIs: https://doi.org/10.1515/freq-2016-9001 .
By now, I have also started a ticket about incorrect ORCIDs:
Daniel-Mietchen
commented
2 years ago Here is also a publisher correction for an incorrect DOI for a cited reference: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41593-020-00755-8 .
The following Wikidata query lists DOIs in Wikidata that do not start with the obligatory "10":
The first 200 results were