search

brave / brave-browser

Brave browser for Android, iOS, Linux, macOS, Windows.
https://brave.com
Mozilla Public License 2.0
17.95k stars 2.35k forks source link

Editing a bookmark in long list causes the browser to jump to top of page #16811

Open Brave-Matt opened 3 years ago

Brave-Matt commented 3 years ago

Description:

Reported behavior is that when bookmarks are edited -- deleted, modified, etc. -- the act of editing causes the browser to jump to the top of the page, rather than retain your current position on the page.

Steps to Reproduce

  1. Ensure you have enough bookmarks to necessitate scrolling down.
  2. Edit a bookmark further down the list

Actual result: Browser jumps to top of bookmarks page after edit.

Expected result: Browser should stay in current position in the list after editing.

Reproduces how often: [Easily reproduced, Intermittent Issue] Easily.

Brave Version: v1.27.84, v1.26.74

Version/Channel Information:

Miscellaneous Information:

User Report: https://community.brave.com/t/when-editing-bookmarks-the-list-scrolls-back-to-the-top-automatically/263322/2

bsclifton commented 3 years ago

Not clear if this is in brave://bookmarks/ or in bookmarks toolbar; followed up to user w/ question

bsclifton commented 3 years ago

update: this is on brave://bookmarks/ 👍

Brave-Matt commented 3 years ago

Added the macOS label here as I'm seeing reports of this behavior on macOS as well.

RexBeans commented 3 years ago

It is in brave://bookmarks/ for instance, if I were to right-click a bookmark from the bookmark toolbar, and choose "Bookmark Manager" from the drop-down. It's not just when editing or moving the bookmarks, even during navigation of the list itself it jumps back to the top.

lazymonkey2 commented 3 years ago

yes, happens on my windows too. it's probably after sync completes that the page is refreshed, and goes back to the top

PorthosSam commented 2 years ago

Still happening in Brave Version 1.33.106 under Windoze 10.

m77e4t commented 2 years ago

@424344 I think you may be right. I tried to replicate it on another brave browser not connected to sync chain (it was brave beta) and I could reproduce it, But, on a brave browser connected to sync chain, a normal edit or deletion of a particular bookmark jumps the screen to the top.

acepilot1944 commented 2 years ago

This issue is still happening on Brave version 1.36.117 & macOS Big Sur. Sometimes Brave automatically scrolls to the top of the page when a Bookmark is edited or deleted, and sometimes it does this WITHOUT such interaction, during normal scrolling.

PorthosSam commented 2 years ago

Thanks, you guys.  It's nice to feel like I'm not alone!  Sam Johnson

On Saturday, March 19, 2022, 10:19:36 PM MDT, acepilot1944 ***@***.***> wrote:

This issue is still happening on Brave version 1.36.117 & macOS Big Sur. Sometimes Brave automatically scrolls to the top of the page when a Bookmark is edited or deleted, and sometimes it does this WITHOUT such interaction, during normal scrolling.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. Triage notifications on the go with GitHub Mobile for iOS or Android. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

rebron commented 2 years ago

There's a workaround for this issue for now by using the bookmarks panel in sidebar. There won't be any jumpiness via using that list to manage and view bookmarks.

lazymonkey2 commented 2 years ago

using the bookmarks panel in sidebar.

yes, but for people with many nested folders and bookmarks the panel is not big enough: I just see the beginning of bookmarks names, so it's almost useless for me right now.

you should make the panel resizable.

deeeeekun commented 2 years ago

There's a workaround for this issue for now by using the bookmarks panel in sidebar. There won't be any jumpiness via using that list to manage and view bookmarks.

This is nice. But the sidebar doesn't appear when in fullscreen mode so I cannot use this workaround, sadly.

zpoison commented 2 years ago

Still no solution? Same problem 6 month later, keeps jumping on top of page

acepilot1944 commented 2 years ago

Forgive me if this is hijacking the thread, but until this gets solved (or even after), it may be useful to use a third-party extension as an alternative bookmark manager. I use Raindrop. This introduces some privacy concerns, rather antithetical to the main point of Brave, but it is very convenient to be able to sort bookmarks in more ways than Chromium-based browsers allow. For example, sorting new-to-old puts your recent bookmarks on top instead of at the bottom of a potentially massive list. Sorting by type (videos, podcasts, articles, etc.) is also useful.

RexBeans commented 2 years ago

I welcome the input, because as you can see from Brave Community's 20 exact same threads about this problem, solving this is not a priority. They can't even get their BAT payment system to work after nearly a year of randomly not paying people what they were promised. My solution to that was to turn off Brave ads, because there was no longer any incentive to use them if there's a 50/50 chance that Brave will either "forget" or never deliver my BAT unless I make repeated attempts to personally beg for what should be an automated payout. Brave would absolutely dominate if they could get their ____ together.

Baneybo commented 1 year ago

A year and a half later and the problem persists. The most user-unfriendly aspect of using Brave; makes me want to jump ship every time I use the Bookmark Manager.

ghost commented 1 year ago

any news?

nicolaipre commented 1 year ago

Following. This is a very annoying issue if you have a bit of bookmarks.

Any updates here, @brave ?

lordparvis commented 1 year ago

this issue is still here and we are waiting for the solution/bug fix

andkonarcade commented 1 year ago

Can confirm, very annoying.

babzo007 commented 1 year ago

Is it possible that brave uses chrome's engine or something like that? Because i have the same bug with chrome when i manage my bookmarks :(

andkonarcade commented 1 year ago

Yes, both are based off Chromium.

babzo007 commented 1 year ago

Yes, both are based off Chromium.

Ok, so it may not be a bug created by Brave itself. Then it may never be solved unless it is fixed with chromium first I guess 😳

the-overdriven commented 7 months ago

Incredibly annoying. Any news on a possible fix or workaround?

speedyhoon commented 6 months ago

Any updates @brave? The Bookmark Manager has been unusable for 4 years! List of duplicates reported.

CarlosMtnez commented 5 months ago

Reorganizing the bookmarks is very annoying; the Bookmarks manager is almost unusable.

lordparvis commented 4 months ago

It's July 7th, and this issue is still here and we are waiting for the solution/bug fix

Shutruk commented 3 months ago

2024 and we still have this bug...

andkonarcade commented 3 months ago

2024 and we still have this bug...

Unfortunately, yes.

lordparvis commented 3 months ago

@andkonarcade @Shutruk It's fixed, been a month or more since then.

Shutruk commented 3 months ago

@andkonarcade @Shutruk It's fixed, been a month or more since then.

Just had the bug before that comment, that's how I found about it.

lordparvis commented 3 months ago

@andkonarcade @Shutruk It's fixed, been a month or more since then.

Just had the bug before that comment, that's how I found about it.

Which platform are you on ? Cause Brave stable, beta, nightly dont have this bug anymore. Just tested Windows 10 and Mac versions, it works fine without jumping to top

andkonarcade commented 3 months ago

@andkonarcade @Shutruk It's fixed, been a month or more since then.

Just had the bug before that comment, that's how I found about it.

Which platform are you on ? Cause Brave stable, beta, nightly dont have this bug anymore. Just tested Windows 10 and Mac versions, it works fine without jumping to top

I'm also using Windows 10 [Version 1.69.153 Chromium: 128.0.6613.85 (Official Build) (64-bit)]. The bookmark manager just jumped back to the top when I deleted a bookmark. Three times. Here is a quick video clip of the fourth time this happened just now:

https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/eaa27cba-f203-4476-9480-6aaced2b37d9

lazymonkey2 commented 3 months ago

yes, still happening to me too (brave current version, win10)

ErinsMatthew commented 1 month ago

Same. Still happens for me:

Brave Version 1.70.126 Chromium: 129.0.6668.100 (Official Build) (arm64) macOS Sonoma Version 14.6.1 (23G93)

binfordn commented 11 hours ago

I am also experiencing this issue. I was excited to try switching to Brave, but unfortunately this is a dealbreaker for me as I have hundreds of bookmarks that I need to keep organized.

Brave Version 1.73.91 Chromium: 131.0.6778.85 (Official Build) (64-bit) Windows 11 Home 23H2 Build 22631.4460