More indexing woes...

[techauthoruk]

Is there an existing issue for this?

• [X] I have searched the existing issues

PDF produced by rinohtype

With an index entry in a heading:

:index:`Safety instructions`
############################

in the table of contents, instead of the page number, I get 'XX'

Source files

See above. I can of course remove the index entry and place it in the body text. Not sure if this is an actual bug or a peculiarity of my installation.

Versions

rinohtype 0.5.5 (in development)
Sphinx 6.0.0b3
Python 3.10.6 (main, Aug 10 2022, 11:40:04) [GCC 11.3.0]
Linux-5.10.16.3-microsoft-standard-WSL2-x86_64-with-glibc2.35

[techauthoruk]

Ah, this only happens in one instance. When 'XX' is displayed in the ToC, it only happens where there is link directly above the heading:

.. _Prepare:

:index:`Preparing` the |prodname| for use
#########################################

[techauthoruk]

Actually, it seems any directive before the heading causes this issue, for example:

.. raw:: html
...

@brechtm is this a rinoh issue or something particular to my install?

[brechtm]

The XX basically means that rinohtype can't resolve the reference or page number. I'll need to investigate to see what's happening exactly. Thanks for the extra info!

[brechtm]

I can't reproduce this (tests-regression/sphinx/test-ref/chapter1.rst - project zip). It could also be a Sphinx bug that's already fixed (I tried with 5.3.0). If you still see this with Sphinx 5.3.0, please provide a minimal Sphinx project triggering the bug.

[techauthoruk]

This occurs with Sphinx version 6.0.0b3 - I will retest with 5.3 and let you know the results

[techauthoruk]

Same thing happens with Sphinx 5.3:

Do you want me to send my demo instance?

[brechtm]

Do you want me to send my demo instance?

Yes, please.

[techauthoruk]

OK...here it is. Bear in mind this is the content I was using for the pdf rear page development, so its a bit all over the place. However, I have edited the hands.rst file to add an index entry:

.. _Prepare:

:index:`Preparing` the |prodname| for use
#########################################

test text

General health and safety
#########################

Hope this helps!

pdf-dev.zip

[brechtm]

Thanks, that helped! Turns out this only happens with index terms in section titles that are rendered out of line (_BodyPageTemplate.chapter_titleflowables). For the book template (and your derivative), that means chapter titles. In some cases, it does output a page number, possibly a wrong one, and the hyperlink is broken. Not yet sure how to fix this...

[techauthoruk]

Now I'm aware of the issue, it isn't a problem (I will not add an index entry to a heading where there is a directive preceding it), but if you can find a fix, that would be great (as I am bound to forget about this!)

[brechtm]

I will not add an index entry to a heading where there is a directive preceding it

To be clear: the issue isn't caused by the directive preceding it. It happens when the index role is used in a chapter title. This is because chapter titles are rendered in a different way (in the Book template, at least).