Closed Kixunil closed 2 years ago
kingonly
commented
2 years ago What exactly you want us to replace? Are you referring to podcasting? Because that's not our specification.
Not sure AMP is going to last either, it's probably going to be replaced by bolt12. In this case it's better to go with something that is supported by all lightning implementations (e.g. keysend) or even better part of the protocol standard (bolt12 hopefully?).
kingonly
commented
2 years ago Btw, when keysend came up in the roundtable with LL, roasbeef stated it's not going to be deprecated soon (even once AMP is enabled). So this also requires some clarification.
Kixunil
commented
2 years ago Are you referring to podcasting?
Yes, sorry for being unclear.
Because that's not our specification.
Where can I raise this issue then?
it's probably going to be replaced by bolt12
Good point!
roasbeef stated it's not going to be deprecated soon
OK, I wanted to avoid supporting keysend just to remove it later but looks like I can't.
kingonly
commented
2 years ago Value block specification is here: https://github.com/Podcastindex-org/podcast-namespace/blob/main/value/value.md#value-element
Dave and Adam (podcasting 2.0 leaders) are well aware of the alternatives and waiting to see where the chips falls.
Btw, I also DMed you on telegram on this.
According to LND doc, keysend shouldn't be used anymore and AMP should be preferred.
Using keysend only puts people into awkward situation when they have to enable a deprecated option.