search

brendanlim / mobile-fu

Automatically detect mobile requests from mobile devices in your Rails application.
http://www.intridea.com/2008/7/21/mobilize-your-rails-application-with-mobile-fu
MIT License
707 stars 195 forks source link

Mobile_fu shows Mobile Site to Search Bots (googlebot) instead of Desktop Site #9

Open rankinit opened 14 years ago

rankinit commented 14 years ago

Mobile_fu shows Mobile Site to Search Bots (googlebot) instead of Desktop Site. This is causing my site not to get indexed properly by google. For example when you do a site:MYSITE.COM in google look at the first link, homepage.. and select "cached" from google's search result page you will see that it is caching my mobile version of my home page instead of the desktop version.

capotej commented 14 years ago

I can confirm this issue as well.

lukas2 commented 13 years ago

me too. any ideas how to fix this?

rankinit commented 13 years ago

in the mobile_fu.rb in the vendor/pugins/mobile_fu/lib/mobile_fu.rb look at the method

is_mobile_device?

Do a check on the request.user_agent to see if it matches any of the publicly known search bots: ["googlebot", "msnbot", "mediapartners-google", "ia_archiver", "ask jeeves", "teoma","msnbot-media", "msnbot-webmaster"]

thats roughly what I did to fix

lukas2 commented 13 years ago

it should be possible somehow to set the default-case to desktop-view. the same seems to happen in internet explorer 8. if the regexp for mobile devices does not match it could render desktop by default, no?

lukas2 commented 13 years ago

hrmh.. well now i fixed it like this:

before_filter :set_default_response_format

def set_default_response_format
   request.format = :html if params[:format].nil?
end

it works with ie8, but i guess ill have to wait and see what the contents of the google cache for our site will be.

rankinit commented 13 years ago

check google webmaster tools there is something called check as google bot which will allow you to see what the google bot see when it visits your page otherwise you are going to have to wait a while for the google cache to update...

Raphomet commented 12 years ago

This seems to be a Rails 3 peculiarity, not explicitly a mobilefu thing. If request.format is nil (for example, when type /_ is requested, which is what Googlebot asks for), Rails prefers templates that match .mobile.erb over .rhtml. Changing our (very old) file extensions from .rhtml to .html.erb fixed this problem for us.

benlangfeld commented 10 years ago

This project is abandoned. Please see the active fork at http://github.com/benlangfeld/mobile-fu. Please test with the released gem and master branch of the new home for the project, and file an issue on the other repo if you still have problems.

See #40.