Open micolous opened 4 years ago
@micolous did you find a solution for dropping all emails? What happens by default when you don't change any settings and a service tries to send a mail?
@benbro It's been a long time since I've looked at this, but from memory this package has no "default configuration", because you'd normally point this at a "real" mail server.
I was running Debian on a Raspberry Pi, and many packages demanded an MTA be installed. However, I was trying to run the system read only (to preserve the life of the SD card), offline, and generally cut down on any unnecessary background tasks (eg: writing to a mail queue in tmpfs
that I'd never read).
The "null" in nullmailer
lead me to believe that this might just drop all the mail out-of-the-box, but in fact "null" was referring to the fact it has no local mail queue and immediately forwards messages to some smarthost (ie: external SMTP server).
However, on further investigation, I found nullmailer
's "protocol handlers" are just binaries in /usr/lib/nullmailer/
which accept a message and return an exit code, so I ended up using /bin/true
as documented above. I don't think that the name localhost
actually mattered -- nullmailer
passes that as a command-line argument to true
(which does nothing with it).
That work-around isn't perfect (for the reasons I opened this issue for), but nullmailer
was still a significant improvement over running a fully-fledged MTA. :)
Thanks, I'll use that. I don't understand why debain removed lsb-invalid-mta.
Implemented as a protocol handler (like
smtp
), this would take a configuration option likeWhen operating in this mode,
nullmailer
would accept mail and always report success, but drop all mail it received on the floor (ie: send to/dev/null
).This would be useful for systems that demand an MTA be installed, but are read-only or the system administrator deliberately wants all mail to be discarded.
Making it an internal option would remove the need to set up a symlink for it, and avoid the need to
exec
another process.Alternatives
One can misuse
/bin/true
as a protocol handler with:Debian formerly had a
lsb-invalid-mta
package, this is no longer present.