search

brumewallet / wallet

The private Ethereum wallet with built-in Tor
https://wallet.brume.money
MIT License
86 stars 12 forks source link

Custom RPC support #20

Closed taxmeifyoucan closed 2 months ago

taxmeifyoucan commented 2 months ago

From what I can tell, the wallet supports only a couple of hardcoded rpc providers and it doesn't allow users to input their own rpc address. This is a crucial feature in privacy wallet. Even if requests are torified, using trusted third party is inferior to your own node. The only current solution is compile it with own address added to the code which is not very practical

hazae41 commented 2 months ago

Not an issue, please propose ideas on other channels

taxmeifyoucan commented 2 months ago

@hazae41 Very disappointing. First of all, this is an issue. Your 'privacy' wallet is just a larp unless you allow users to customize RPC. Missing a basic feature for trustless operation = a serious issue.

I can see you find this as more of a feature request, in that case a suggest you add flag to label this issue as 'feature request' which is a regular way of tracking requested features in public github repo. In case you are choosing other project management with less transparency, please point me to right channel instead. Your readme doesn't specify any and your comment doesn't recommend any channel either

hazae41 commented 2 months ago

You can discuss such things on Twitter, Discord, SimpleX

All links there

https://brume.money

https://hazae41.me

hazae41 commented 2 months ago

Or better in GitHub Discussion if you want a detailed public feature proposal