buildingSMART / IDS

Computer interpretable (XML) standard to define Information Delivery Specifications for BIM (mainly used for IFC)
Other
167 stars 52 forks source link

Model Element Author specification using IDS #234

Open femesq opened 4 months ago

femesq commented 4 months ago

When creating a BIM model, we have the Model Element Author - which defines who is responsible for modeling each element.

Initially, this verification seemed to be viable using the entities IfcOwnerHistory and IfcPerson / IfcOrganization. But reading the documentation (and examples), I couldn't understand how this would be possible to go down this deep relation. Eg.:

IfcWall -> IfcOwnerHistory (attribute) -> OwningUser (attribute) - type: IfcPersonAndOrganization -> IfcPerson | IfcOrganization

Is this possible to achieve currently?


When moving to requirements specification, this could be even more granular and allow a third party to be responsible for providing such information, although someone else is the modeler (who populates the property/attribute in the model).

Is it possible to define who is responsible for meeting this requirement using the IDS, or because it is impossible to check (since the IFC will not have such data), is this outside the scope of the IDS?

mysterieux30 commented 4 months ago

I think not yet

CBenghi commented 2 months ago

This is out of scope for version 1.0. It cannot be done with IDS. You could do this with MVDXML, I think.