butterproject / butter-desktop

All the free parts of Popcorn Time
http://butterproject.org/
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
4.29k stars 1.08k forks source link

Chat box on Butter App #138

Open Glamorgal opened 8 years ago

Glamorgal commented 8 years ago

What about adding chat system to Butter? So we can communicate with each other and make friends, or share everything. Waitting for your suggestions.

Octopixell commented 8 years ago

I'd say add it as a plugin later, only for people that want it.

Geczy commented 8 years ago

No

prcastro commented 8 years ago

I'm also against it. Hard to maintain and to moderate.

Octopixell commented 8 years ago

It would turn in one of those chatboxes you see on these anime websites.. Just a load of crap and no real conversation..

Glamorgal commented 8 years ago

Maybe you're right. It would turn to one of those chatboxes but we could give it a try. And pretty sure there will be a lot of people to moderate that chat. But it was just an idea. :)

Octopixell commented 8 years ago

@Glamorgal any idea is more than welcome ofcourse! :+1: Like I said, you could maybe make it as a plugin, people that would want it, could use it. But it'd have to be seperately maintained and definitely seperated from the core project.

Glamorgal commented 8 years ago

OK I got it :) Thank you!

SrPatinhas commented 8 years ago

@Glamorgal its a good idea if made well from scratch, but like @Octopixell said, it will be a plugin, maybe a good plugin to ask on app install? :p but maybe it could have this features:

This is just some ideas, but for this to work should be well done and well think of ;)

kisPocok commented 8 years ago

It's nice, but it moves away us from Butter app's goal. I suggest to keep our poor functionality as a strict rule. Anyway it would be nice if plugin system comes real!

NoNameProvided commented 8 years ago

+1 against it. Hard to maintain and to moderate. A chat is totally unrelated to Butter.

cfacundo commented 8 years ago

-1

Nelrann commented 8 years ago

-1000

Draxler commented 8 years ago

:-1:
No chaty on Butter .. only watching and enjoying ... There's tons of chater options out there which make posible for anyone to chat live while watching whatever on Butter (if that make sence).. No need for chat box to have Butter name on it ... And like others already said. This have nothing to do with Butter, also chatting while watching have no sence.. For chat in general people have other sources for that ..

xpnpm commented 8 years ago

@Draxler Right

kisPocok commented 8 years ago

I suggest to close this bug for now.

SrPatinhas commented 8 years ago

i see you guys dont have friends to share movies or other that you like or see the real point to have this as a plugin, that would be as a plugin, not in the app itself, witch one of you would install it if you want. and im up for this plugin to share movies or shows or whatever with my friends.

@Glamorgal i will not close this because to avoid to be duplicated. but later will be pass to another repo of plugins.

Octopixell commented 8 years ago

@SrPatinhas are there any types of documentation or ideas we can read into about future plugin development?

SrPatinhas commented 8 years ago

@Octopixell soon we will have the documentation ;)

Octopixell commented 8 years ago

@SrPatinhas you Sir, are amazing, thanks! As soon as we can write plugins people can just make Butter what they want it to be, rather than have these types of discussions where people don't even bother to say something other than -1 or no :)

xpnpm commented 8 years ago

@SrPatinhas Create a Simple application for movies, and easy to use, small size .. This is important and Good idea ( Notifications ) plugin is important more than Chat!

Octopixell commented 8 years ago

@mo5tlef I do hope you understand it wouldn't be the core team working on things like chat plugins and the likes. If it was important enough for the core team to work on it, it would be in the core. ;)

xpnpm commented 8 years ago

@Octopixell Ok, Go ahead. But u are wasting your time Chating is everywhere butter Must be ( Movies time )

Draxler commented 8 years ago

@SrPatinhas

If you want to have this as a plugin system, OK, as long this is not intergrated into app it self.

But i'm more concerne with how will this chat plugin actualy works. Will this plugin collect live all Butter userbase or how would this actualy works?

rufolangus commented 8 years ago

No. If anything facebook integration. Like & share -> link opens butter to whatever they shared.

vankasteelj commented 8 years ago

why might be done, though, is adding our own comment section on official providers (for example: a disq instance), for people to comment the Open catalog. But bare in mind that butter relies heavily on providers, it's not Netflix, shipping its own content.

xaiki commented 8 years ago

as @vankasteelj and @SrPatinhas said this is a good plugin idea, let's keep it around, then butter builders will decide weather they want to ship this or not.