search

buttilda / Another-One-Bites-the-Dust

Process ALL the ores!
http://minecraft.curseforge.com/mc-mods/221863-another-one-bites-the-dust
24 stars 21 forks source link

Gravel ores #115

Open buttilda opened 8 years ago

buttilda commented 8 years ago

similar to the ones added by TiCon but with the dynamism of AOBD

Voxel-Friend commented 8 years ago

People can harvest gravel ores by causing them to fall on a torch or flower. If you can prevent this I'd say it's a great idea. Great implementation of shovel mining levels.

UndeadZeratul commented 8 years ago

Between the shovel mining levels for gravel ores, and the axe mining levels of the oreberry bushes, it's about time mods utilize them.

I do agree though, if you can prevent the ore dropping when falling on something like a torch, or pressure plate, or whatever else people in vanilla use to harvest massive amounts of sand/gravel, that would be great; might even re-add them to my worldgen.

buttilda commented 8 years ago

Could simply make them not fall with gravity and work like dirt?

UndeadZeratul commented 8 years ago

Let me guess, the falling is hardcoded to break itself when it collides with such a block?

buttilda commented 8 years ago

It drops itself as an item if it falls into the block space of a block it can't replace. e.g.: it can replace air or tall grass, so it will just turn "solid". It can't replace a torch, though it can enter its space due to the torch not having a collision box, so it drops itself as an item (otherwise you'd either lose the torch or the gravel, which is not ideal)

UndeadZeratul commented 8 years ago

Losing the torch would be ok in my opinion, it's just a torch. Is it possible to make it drop the block it falls into as an item?

Either way, preventing the physics would be the simplest answer, but then it makes them inconsistent with their TiC counterparts.

hron84 commented 8 years ago

@UndeadZeratul It's not about a torch. Falling blocks drops itself on slabs to and you can imagine a diamond slab what you definitelly not want to loose just because a falling block. But anyway, this is not how Minecraft works. Falling blocks are falling and it already has a well-defined behavior that shouldn't changed.

I do not like to not make these ores falling. If they're rare enough, it does not causes a big issue if someone mine them with a torch. TiCon gravel ores works on this way and "Gravel ores" should have a consistent behaviour.

buttilda commented 8 years ago

I agree with @hron84. It's a small exploit that doesn't really break progression in any way and just makes harvesting ores take a tiny bit less time. You'd still need a shovel that can mine the ore in order to mine the bottom one. And the gravel ore clusters are small and short, you don't get more than 4-5 in a pile, which means you won't even save that much time by using the torch-mining technique.