search

bvaughn / react-window

React components for efficiently rendering large lists and tabular data
https://react-window.now.sh/
MIT License
15.72k stars 782 forks source link

Any Functionality like WindowScroller in react-window #662

Closed gaoyuan1223m closed 3 weeks ago

gaoyuan1223m commented 2 years ago

I would wonder why WindowScroller is removed from 'react-window' or is there any alternative to WindowScroller in 'react-window'?

charkour commented 2 years ago

I'm interested as well. Perhaps this package will work: https://github.com/FedericoDiRosa/react-window-scroller

gaoyuan1223m commented 2 years ago

@charkour Thanks a lot!

epurban commented 1 year ago

Hey @charkour @gaoyuan1223m , were either of you able to get this working? For me, introducing react-window-scroller causes the cell components to unmount on every render, which leads to terrible performance.

charkour commented 1 year ago

Hey @epurban, I ended up switching to TanStack/virtual since it is newer, receiving active support, and is smaller. It solved my issue.

Sorry I cannot be much help, but figured I'd let you know how I moved forward.

patorjk commented 4 months ago

I'm also wondering about this. The react-window package is fantastic, but for one of my use cases I wound up with a list that needed to be scrolled by its container. Basically the use case seen here: https://codesandbox.io/p/sandbox/7yzzw92xw1?file=%2Fsrc%2FUsers.jsx

I wound up add react-virtualized to my project too, and while it works, but I feel a bit strange having both in my project and worry that react-virtualized may be on its way out. The react-window-scroller package mentioned above doesn't look like its maintained anymore.

epurban commented 4 months ago

Hey @patorjk, as @charkour recommended, I also switched to tanstack virtual for most of my virtualized list use cases.

patorjk commented 4 months ago

That library turned out to be awesome. I did not expect it to handle my exact use case but it's literally their first example. I'm going to need to test some more but thank you for seconding that recommendation!