search

bwheelz36 / ParticlePhaseSpace

Import, analysis, and export of particle phase space data
https://bwheelz36.github.io/ParticlePhaseSpace/
GNU General Public License v3.0
13 stars 8 forks source link

Extended References on Toolkits & Standards #157

Closed ax3l closed 1 year ago

ax3l commented 1 year ago

Thank you for the JOSS submission in https://github.com/openjournals/joss-reviews/issues/5375 .

This is question is related to #151 and #156.

Recent Toolkits for Beam Analysis

Related to paper

There are some additional open source codes providing similar functionality to this code; these include the p2sat (lesnat (2021)) and postpic (Kuschel (2022)) codes.

Over the recent years, a couple of our colleagues implemented new analysis packages that might be interesting to either be compatible with with cite as more recent related works. In particular, I am thinking of these packages:

Accelerator Physics Codes

Additionally to the Wikipedia page linked as “Accelerator Physics Codes” (2022) and maintained by our colleague David Sagan, maybe these catalogue that we created in the Consortium for Advanced Modeling of Particle Accelerators (CAMPA) are useful:

Related by biased, I do work on this set of accelerator modeling codes:

The paper quotes

Each of these programs will typically utilize their own unique format for saving and loading phase space data. This means that getting these programs to ‘speak’ to each other is generally a substantial amount of work.

I fully agree. We hope to overcome this, since we actively standardize I/O with openPMD in many of these codes (see #156). Thus, the first sentence could maybe be rephrased slightly or cite projects like openPMD (2015)?

bwheelz36 commented 1 year ago

Hi @ax3l Thanks for enlightening me about these other tools! I have added references to them in the above commit.

bwheelz36 commented 1 year ago

@ax3l, I updated as per your comments in this commit (sorry I forgot to tag this issue). I had to make a few more minor changes to fix some typos, but that commit contains the bulk of the corrections

ax3l commented 1 year ago

Thanks a lot @bwheelz36. Please excuse the delay.

I noticed one detail and commented a suggestion in