Back button is too hard to acquire with mouse

bwinton / TabCenter

Firefox add-on for arranging tabs vertically

https://testpilot.firefox.com/experiments/tab-center

210 stars 56 forks source link

Back button is too hard to acquire with mouse #142

Open potch opened 8 years ago

potch commented 8 years ago

Would prefer the tab side-rail begin below toolbars, and let the back button keep its Fitts-law-satisfying location.

bwinton commented 8 years ago

I'ld definitely like to see this as an experiment, since it would also solve Michael Verdi's problem with new tabs and typing urls… @ericawright, can you try to quickly whip this up when you get a chance?

kodawah commented 8 years ago

i agree, either below or in the same position with just movable items

ghost commented 8 years ago

This could be a good candidate for the feature-flag a/b testing ability in test pilot. /cc @lmorchard

paulkoan commented 7 years ago

This is a routine issue for me.

Go to click back button
Overshoot by 15px triggering tabcenter open animation
Come back > 15px back to where the Back button was
Click intending to hit back, but instead hit "New tab"
Close new tab
Hit "Back" more carefully

heftig commented 7 years ago

Putting the tab sidebar on the right instead of the left could also be an option to avoid moving the back button.

Perhaps the hamburger button could stay in its corner, too, with the tab toolbar items to its immediate left.

BTW, what happens if the UI direction is right-to-left?

paulkoan commented 7 years ago

Another option would be to have a longer "open" delay when you mouse into the "New tab / search" area - longer than when choosing a tab. So if you overshoot the back button, you have a chance to get back to it before the tab center opens up.

My workaround is to have another icon in between the back button and the tab center sidebar.

jordiorlando commented 7 years ago

Any news on this? Is it on the roadmap or has it been abandoned?

bwinton commented 7 years ago

No-one has stepped up to work on it recently.

mccoys commented 7 years ago

This issue is particularly annoying when the "auto-shrink" option is activated because the vertical tabs bar keeps hiding the navigation bar.

I would like to concur to the earlier suggestion that the "new tab" icon be below the navigation bar. Not on its left.

In addition, when one particular tab is hovered, do not expand the whole bar, but only that one tab. Even though that does not relate specifically to the "back button" problem, it would help the overall accessibility of the buttons on the top-left corner.

ghost commented 7 years ago

If it can be useful, I use Tree Style Tab to simulate a vertical tab list. I haven't got this problem, so I let you a screenshot to understand why. It could be the solution to place vertical sidebar of tabs below the top and not at left of the top.