search

c-frame / aframe-physics-system

community-maintained fork of n5ro's aframe-physics-system
https://c-frame.github.io/aframe-physics-system/
MIT License
43 stars 11 forks source link

Cannon driver in worker mode has lots of issues #7

Open diarmidmackenzie opened 2 years ago

diarmidmackenzie commented 2 years ago

Previously the Cannon examples used a mix of local & worker drivers.

I updated the examples so that there is a version of each for local and one for worker. This exercise revealed a number of problems with the worker driver in the current code:

1 - Compound shapes example does not work at all

Error:

aframe-physics-system.js:18755 Uncaught Error: Unimplemented shape type: %s
    at serializeShape (aframe-physics-system.js:18755:11)
    at Array.map (<anonymous>)
    at module.exports.serializeBody (aframe-physics-system.js:18620:25)
    at WorkerDriver.addBody (aframe-physics-system.js:18031:65)
    at o.addBody (aframe-physics-system.js:18455:17)
    at i._play (aframe-physics-system.js:16603:17)
    at i.tick (aframe-physics-system.js:16578:12)
    at HTMLElement.value (a-scene.js:739:34)
    at HTMLElement.value (a-scene.js:789:36)
    at bind.js:12:17

2 - Constraints example doesn't work at all.

b09bff94-0230-42fa-8b9a-8becd4f0f90a:6281 Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading 'quaternion')
    at ConeTwistConstraint.update (b09bff94-0230-42fa-8b9a-8becd4f0f90a:6281:11)
    at ConeTwistConstraint.update (b09bff94-0230-42fa-8b9a-8becd4f0f90a:6476:44)
    at World.internalStep (b09bff94-0230-42fa-8b9a-8becd4f0f90a:12903:11)
    at World.step (b09bff94-0230-42fa-8b9a-8becd4f0f90a:12631:12)
    at LocalDriver.step (b09bff94-0230-42fa-8b9a-8becd4f0f90a:13547:14)
    at step (b09bff94-0230-42fa-8b9a-8becd4f0f90a:13737:12)

3 - "force-push" component doesn't work at all (multiple examples)

4 - sandbox example - constraint between green cone & purple box does not work.

5 - sweeper example - sweeper bar does not move the blocks

6 - ttl example - entities fall through the plane when they should land on it.

None of these issues has been investigated yet. If we want to investigate them, we should split out into separate issues to track each investigation.

Bundling together as one issue for now, as it's not clear there's sufficient motivation to work on the cannon worker driver, when we also have Ammo drive and PhysX available, which are probably both more performant, more functional and more reliable.

Maybe time to deprecate the Cannon Worker driver?

kylebakerio commented 2 years ago

I think that sounds reasonable for now, and is de-facto the case. If anyone wants to pick it up, that's always available to anyone who is motivated, but no reason to advertise it as current. It hasn't worked for quite some time at this point anyways, right? years?