Not working with es6 getters

[ricardomatias]

I have the following code

    get scale() {
        const createScale = (root, scaleType, noteType) => {
            console.log('MEMOIZE', root, scaleType, noteType);
            return new Scale(root, scaleType, noteType);
        };

        return memoize(createScale)(this._root, this._scaleType, this._noteType);
    }

Even though the arguments are the same, the createScale function is still called twice, thus returning different instances of Scale. Any ideas? Is this specific to ES6 class getters?

[planttheidea]

You appear to be creating a new function and executing it every time scale is called?

[ricardomatias]

Yes, I'm using getters so I only derive the scale, once the someone tries to access the property. As an improvement I thought about adding memoizing, but somehow the function createScale is being triggered, even when the arguments don't change.

[planttheidea]

Well of course it is ... You are creating a new memoized function and executing it every time that scale is called. You should make that function a standalone function (created once, not on every execution) and then it will work as you expect.

[ricardomatias]

That sounds rather obvious.. these getters tied my brain into a knot. Thanks for the help x)