search

camptocamp / puppet-dell

dell specific installations (openmanage and others)
21 stars 37 forks source link

Resource ordering #36

Closed jschaeff closed 6 years ago

jschaeff commented 11 years ago

The dell::hwtools class needs the configuration of the package repository wich will only be setup afterwards (in dell::openmanage).

The ordering does not seem straightforward to describe because the 2 classes should stay "independent" ...

mcanevet commented 10 years ago

@jschaeff is it still the case with latest version of the module ?

jschaeff commented 10 years ago

Yes, it's still the case. I forced the ordering by adding the dependency :

--- a/manifests/openmanage/debian.pp +++ b/manifests/openmanage/debian.pp @@ -212,4 +212,6 @@ SNnmxzdpR6pYJGbEDdFyZFe5xHRWSlrC3WTbzg== before => Service['dataeng'], }

raphink commented 9 years ago

I merged https://github.com/camptocamp/puppet-dell/pull/45. Does it fix it?

stumped2 commented 9 years ago

tag 0.1.1 still has ordering issues.

It's trying to start dataeng before the package is installed. Then after trying to start the service, it then tries to install the package that contains the service. Then after trying to install the package, it then tried to add the repo from which to install.

Ultimately, it should progress as this:

repo -> package -> service

whereas right now it flows:

service -> package -> repo.

(trying on ubuntu 14.04)

raphink commented 9 years ago

@stumped2 @jschaeff does https://github.com/camptocamp/puppet-dell/pull/50 fix it?

stumped2 commented 9 years ago

@raphink I just finished getting test-kitchen + puppet set up, I'll test out #50 and let you know.

EDIT: commented on the PR.

raphink commented 9 years ago

Cool. How does test-kitchen+puppet compare with beaker?

stumped2 commented 9 years ago

@raphink I originally started out my SysAdmin days using chef, so I am sort of biased towards test-kitchen since it was such a great tool in the chef world.

For the most part, test kitchen + puppet is great, if you don't want to do advanced/weird things since the puppet provisioner docs are sorely lacking.

I did a quick glance at beaker, and it looks cool, but it would take a bit for me to convert over to beaker setup from test kitchen.

raphink commented 9 years ago

What are the advantages of test-kitchen?

stumped2 commented 9 years ago

In what aspect do you mean?