capactio / capact

Simple way to manage applications and infrastructure.
https://capact.io
Apache License 2.0
79 stars 19 forks source link

Investigate dynamic TypeInstances support in umbrella workflows #688

Closed pkosiec closed 2 years ago

pkosiec commented 2 years ago

Description

Currently, our PostgreSQL installation Implementation produces static TypeInstance for PostgreSQL Helm release (link). The reason is the current limitation of accessing our dynamic TypeInstances in umbrella workflows.

In this case, the umbrella workflow is the Mattermost installation (link).

If we used the Helm template storage, the postgresql artifact would contain:

backend:
  context:
    goTemplate: |
      host: '{{ template "postgresql.primary.fullname" . }}'
      port: '{{ template "postgresql.port" . }}'
      defaultDBName: '{{ template "postgresql.database" . }}'
      superuser:
        username: '{{ template "postgresql.username" . }}'
        password: '{{ template "postgresql.password" . }}'
    release:
      driver: secrets
      name: example-release
      namespace: default
value: null

And the Mattermost installation umbrella workflow steps require these rendered values, to:

AC

Ideas how to solve it:

  1. Change the way how we run nested workflow: maybe the Engine shouldn't render one huge workflow, but schedule and run separate Argo Workflows instead? Every workflow would have dedicated upload/download steps
    • Investigated as a part of #546
  2. Save rendered value under different property in the artifact (e.g. .rendered) and use that in umbrella workflow
    • Ignore it during TypeInstance upload
    • It probably won't work for other backends, which base on actual TypeInstance existing in Hub
  3. Hack: Add "fetcher" container which fetches Helm template storage backend and renders the template
    • We would need to fake TypeInstance ID, because there's no TypeInstance yet
    • It won't work for other backends, which base on actual TypeInstance existing in Hub
    • Probably no-go

Reason and use cases

See https://github.com/capactio/capact/issues/604