search

capport-wg / architecture

Captive Portal Architecture
Other
10 stars 8 forks source link

Rephrase 3.2.1: associate rather than give #117

Closed klarose closed 4 years ago

klarose commented 4 years ago

Benjamin writes,

Section 3.2.1

Each instance of User Equipment interacting with the Captive Network MUST be given an identifier that is unique among User Equipment interacting at that time.

side note: "MUST be given" gets a knee-jerk "by whom?" response from me. It's probably okay for this document to not specify, though, as it may depend on the nature of the Captive Network.

I suggest:

perhaps "given" is the wrong term here? Should we rephrase to "The Captive Network MUST associate the User Equipment with an identifier that is unique among User Equipment that is interacting at that time?"