Component audit

[metonym]

An extensive component audit must be performed before entertaining a v1 release.

Identify non-reactive props

• [x] ProgressIndicator currentIndex: issue #343
• [x] DatePicker (ranged): issue #234
• [ ] SelectableTile: issue #428

Identify inconsistent or confusing prop/value nomenclature

• [ ] size values are inconsistent (e.g. "small" vs."sm", undefined vs. "default")
• [x] icon props are inconsistent
  • [x] some icons are the Carbon Icon type, while icon for HeaderAction is an object (#371 )
• [ ] ambiguous prop value (For PaginationNav, the page prop is an index value while in Pagination the same prop represents the current page number)
• [ ] "is it slottable?" - make prop names more semantic (e.g. "labelText" must be a string while "label" signifies that it can be slottable)
• [ ] isOpen inconsistent with open (https://github.com/IBM/carbon-components-svelte/issues/461)

Identify inconsistent use of dispatched events

• [x] ComboBox, Dropdown dispatches "select", "clear" events; MultiSelect does not (#378, fixed in #380 )

Identify feature delta compared to flagship Carbon Design System

The basic expectation is that components from the library are compatible with the latest CSS from carbon-components.

What features are missing compared to their counterparts in the flagship Carbon library?

Identify components with insufficient or incomplete documentation

• ComposedModal
• UIShell
• Checkbox
• FileUploader
• DatePicker ...

Refactor components w/ major breaking changes

• HeaderActionSearch (#395 )

---

Misc

Composed components should support dynamic create/update behavior

• [not fixed] Tabs, TabContent, Tab: issue #368
• [not fixed] ContentSwitcher, Switch

[orta]

I'd recommend also taking a look at the breakpoints for the UIShell when you have both a sidebar and navigation items, as at larger width it shows both

[orta]

( not trying to pile on, and I'm finding work-arounds by using the DOM API - so it's not a blocker for me, but better to report I assume )

Spotted this also Dropdown selectedIndex also is not reactive. Same with ContentSwitcher.

[metonym]

@orta I'll open separate issues for those

[ispyinternet]

Should Toggle and ToggleSmall be a configurable Toggle ?

[metonym]

@ispyinternet I agree. Besides the size, Toggle and ToggleSmall are pretty much identical. Related https://github.com/carbon-design-system/carbon/issues/6653