search

carevealed / cavppers

6 stars 3 forks source link

pbcorethat - technical - validation #19

Closed klipska closed 6 years ago

klipska commented 7 years ago

PBCore does not validate. In addition to the lines with problems that Oxygen points out, I think Identifier, Title and Description will need to be repeated after PBCorePart in order to validate.

dericed commented 7 years ago

a few reasons that the pbcore is invalid.

  1. Both Institution and Institution URL are mapped to @collectionSource, but there can only be once. Temporarily I used @collectionSource and @collectionSourceAGAIN (which is invalid). Which value is intended to map to @collectionSource?
dericed commented 7 years ago
  1. We currently don't have an instantiationIdentifier for the instantiation referenced by the Gauge and Format column. What can we use for that identifier?
klipska commented 7 years ago
  1. collectionsource should be Institution. Let's use this for Institution URL: <pbcoreIdentifier source="Institution" annotation="Institution URL">https://someinstitutionURL.com</pbcoreIdentifier>
  2. Is this the <instantiationPhysical> v.s. <instantiationDigital> question? Are there any other options of what to call this so that it could refer to either an original physical format OR to a born digital file? If not, is there a way we can direct the script to use one tag or another when we run it?
dericed commented 6 years ago

i think everything here is covered in https://github.com/cavpp/cavppers/pull/33/commits. I used the object id for the instantiation of the original object so that looks like:

    <pbcoreInstantiation>
      <instantiationIdentifier source="CAVPP" annotation="Object Identifier">cabesc_000001</instantiationIdentifier>
      <instantiationPhysical>mp4</instantiationPhysical>
      <instantiationLocation>XYZ Place</instantiationLocation>
      <instantiationMediaType>Moving Image</instantiationMediaType>
      <instantiationGenerations>Copy</instantiationGenerations>
      <instantiationColors>Color</instantiationColors>
      <instantiationTracks>Sound</instantiationTracks>
      <instantiationLanguage>eng</instantiationLanguage>
      <instantiationAnnotation source="Total Number of Reels or Tapes">1 File of 1</instantiationAnnotation>
    </pbcoreInstantiation>