carloscuesta / gitmoji

An emoji guide for your commit messages. 😜
https://gitmoji.dev
MIT License
15.74k stars 799 forks source link

Emoji for things related to privacy #1445

Closed DrMaxNix closed 1 year ago

DrMaxNix commented 1 year ago

Emoji symbol

πŸ“‘

Emoji code

:satellite:

Emoji description

Changes related to privacy

Describe the use case of your emoji

I just added a <meta name="referrer" content="same-origin"> header to one of my projects which improves user privacy when clicking on external links. Though I didn't find an adequate gitmoji for my commit message. So I'd like to propose a gitmoji for commits related to privacy.

This can be used for all sorts of commits that improve privacy of users and would be a fitting counterpart to the πŸ”’οΈ Fix security issues gitmoji. The πŸ“‘ :satelite: emoji first came to mind as a symbol for "spying on someone", but I'm open for discussion :)

Is this use case covered by an existing emoji?

No ❌

Does this emoji fall into the "how" or the "what" category?

Examples

πŸ“‘ add referrer policy πŸ“‘ fix data leak in api request πŸ“‘ remove unnecessary input for telephone number πŸ“‘ ask for cookie consent

Validations

camipozas commented 1 year ago

@carloscuesta can I take it?

brds commented 1 year ago

Hello! I was about to propose "βœ‹" as gitmoji for the same use case and found this issue :-)

The βœ‹ hand position can be interpreted as a human saying "stop". I think it would be meaningful for privacy-related stuff. This symbol seems to be a convention: for example, it is used in iOS and MacOS settings to illustrate the "Privacy & Security" sections.

What do you think?

camipozas commented 1 year ago

Hello!

Honestly I think the πŸ–οΈ doesn't be fully representative about privacy. Maybe would be πŸ’Ύ but doesn't convince me. What do you think?

Freso commented 1 year ago

My first thought when reading the title before opening up the issue was that πŸ•΅οΈ would be the proposal. I’m not sure I agree that :satellite: would be the most intuitive option for this purpose. :artificial_satellite: would probably even be more intuitive.

flyri0 commented 1 year ago

What do you guys think about this: πŸ›‘οΈ

The shield symbol is already widely publicized when it comes to privacy. And if you search for icons that represent privacy, the shield always appears.

Examples πŸ›‘οΈ add referrer policy πŸ›‘οΈ fix data leak in api request πŸ›‘οΈ remove unnecessary input for telephone number πŸ›‘οΈ ask for cookie consent

Thanyanit-J commented 1 year ago

What about eye πŸ‘€ or πŸ‘οΈ? Privacy = asking your users: "Do you want to be seen or not?"

Several icons related to privacy also use a single eye or a lock as a symbol, but we already used :lock: for security. Therefore, eye.

Thanyanit-J commented 1 year ago

What do you guys think about this: πŸ›‘οΈ

The shield symbol is already widely publicized when it comes to privacy. And if you search for icons that represent privacy, the shield always appears.

Examples πŸ›‘οΈ add referrer policy πŸ›‘οΈ fix data leak in api request πŸ›‘οΈ remove unnecessary input for telephone number πŸ›‘οΈ ask for cookie consent

I think the shield is skewed towards security more than privacy. Probably thanks to Microsoft Defender and several Anti-virus software logo.

danielwerg commented 1 year ago

I wouldn't associate privacy with πŸ“‘ emoji. I think πŸ‘οΈ fits the best, πŸ•΅πŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ is also fine option but there too many details for my liking.

vhoyer commented 1 year ago

if it wasn't already suggested, I'd suggest using the :shield: myself, but I can see your point. But in a different direction, why don't we expand the meaning of :lock::

-Fix security issues.
+Fix security or privacy issues.
johannchopin commented 1 year ago

I'm completly in favour of extending the :lock: πŸ”’οΈ gitmoji @vhoyer.

connorjs commented 1 year ago

When reading title of "privacy" I also thought to extend existing security.

Tag @flyri0 @brds @DrMaxNix for thoughts on using lock instead (y’all recommended other emoji)

DrMaxNix commented 1 year ago

Even though security and privacy are two different things I'm not against extending the :lock: emoji to also include privacy..

brds commented 1 year ago

The lock is fine for me πŸ‘ Thank you for the follow-up!

connorjs commented 1 year ago

@carloscuesta + @vhoyer - I’ll look at creating a PR for this update to lock gitmoji. I’ve wanted to commit to the repo for a while.