carloscuesta / gitmoji

An emoji guide for your commit messages. 😜
https://gitmoji.dev
MIT License
15.54k stars 802 forks source link

🤝 Review code #986

Closed lsagetlethias closed 2 years ago

lsagetlethias commented 2 years ago

Hello @carloscuesta :sunglasses:!

Describe the use case of your emoji

When working in team, gives a way to mark code part of a review resolution and avoid micro atomic commits.

Is this use case covered by an existing emoji?

Yes, with 🐛 but not entirely ; or yes if we allow micro commits in our repo or if we don't care about reviews commits.

Does this emoji fall into the "how" category?

I don't think so.

Examples

:handshake: Handle review from @user :handshake: Apply review from @user :handshake: Change logic as suggested

carloscuesta commented 2 years ago

Hey @lsagetlethias thanks for opening an issue!

We discussed this emoji before in https://github.com/carloscuesta/gitmoji/issues/348 it was part of the convention but it was removed.

If you think a bit deeper about it when someone requests a code review, it is because there's an issue or a potential improvement, that change can be categorized using one of the existing emojis.

Using your examples:

:handshake: Handle review from @user :handshake: Apply review from @user

This example falls into the "how" category.

:handshake: Change logic as suggested

This one should be covered with 👔 or a fixup of the previous commit where the logic was introduced.

You'll find more discussion on the thread I linked.

Thanks!

lsagetlethias commented 2 years ago

Seems fair! Thank you for the ref.