Closed nschneid closed 2 years ago
[Reddit task_001:997]
Any reason that "for_every" should be considered as a single target marked as RateUnit? para_cada i guess in spanish...
If not, then we need a label that allows for correspondence (#70 above) --- "as applied to" sense.
This is hard. Let me discuss this one with Jena and @svivek in our next meeting.
Aryaman: Exchange sense of FOR? Because you are being rewarded.
Removing the notion of rate which comes from "every":
However "for each" and "for every" seem pretty idiomatic as ways to express rate. Should they be MWEs?
For almost every bird I see I know what kind it is. (a regularity of correspondence, not necessarily a rate) (paraphrase: Whenever I see a bird I usually know what kind it is.)
Maybe the word "rate" is our problem, because it suggests a numeric quantity, and we should just interpret RateUnit as a relationship of recurrence.
Another tricky one: "on average" (It takes people an hour on average). Putting Extent for now since it's kind of a hedge, but not sure that captures it very well.
I wonder if we should generalize RateUnit
to something like SetIteration
(whose temporal counterpart is Frequency
).
Could also apply to "in general" (#25).
Or we could simply broaden Extent
to cover RateUnit
and these other set-wise quantifiers.
After discussion with @jenahwang: SetIteration seems better than RateUnit; concerned about overloading Extent too much.
Just to throw out another option: if RateUnit
or SetIteration
is hard to justify because it's so sparse, what about applying the label Configuration
for some miscellaneous cases just as we do for Temporal
?
Just to throw out another option: if
RateUnit
orSetIteration
is hard to justify because it's so sparse, what about applying the labelConfiguration
for some miscellaneous cases just as we do forTemporal
?
Per @jenahwang, it's more frequent for Korean since the equivalents of "each"/"every" are adpositional.
Renaming RateUnit
-> SetIteration
seems like a good option.
A rate based on iterating over a set.
Reminiscent of: