search

carmls / snacs-guidelines

Semantic Network of Adposition and Case Supersenses: Annotation Guidelines
2 stars 0 forks source link

AGAINST #21

Open nschneid opened 4 years ago

nschneid commented 4 years ago

In the data: "That is the dumbest reason against suicide." (i.e. reason to oppose suicide)

I think the core meaning of AGAINST is force-dynamic rather than spatial, causal, or interpersonal. Thus the supersenses are not a perfect fit. Should we define Direction to also include direction of force application? (Are there other adpositions like this?)

For now we are getting by with Direction, Co-Agent, and Beneficiary.

[Reddit task_007:926]

esmanning commented 4 years ago

Revisiting that "reason against suicide" example - we were thinking maybe Theme by analogy to "reason FOR", but that feels weird for AGAINST. Is that ok? Is there something better? (It was left blank in the original adjudication)

nschneid commented 4 years ago

Can't think of anything better

esmanning commented 4 years ago

Another odd against:

Once dreads become not-completely-suicidal AGAINST supercaps Reddit task_010 new_doc id = 4b5ca436-953c-178e-6106-7a8cd7a3283c sent_id = 1

Tentatively we've called this Circumstance, as in "once it becomes not-completely-suicidal to use dreads when fighting supercaps" but ehhhh

esmanning commented 3 years ago

Another, from lpp_11:

Clap your hands, one AGAINST the other sent_id = lpp_1943.615

And he began again to clap his hands, one against the other. sent_id = lpp_1943.619

We called these Goal