carpentries / instructor-training

Instructor Training
https://carpentries.github.io/instructor-training/
Other
175 stars 290 forks source link

Make rubric easier to use #1248

Open brownsarahm opened 3 years ago

brownsarahm commented 3 years ago

We got feedback from multiple trainees that the time allotted to reading the rubric before practicing teaching the second time was not enough. They also shared that they were unsure of how to use the rubric, practically, that they wished it was a fillable template.

I think better instructions /easier use would also help with the timing issue.

emcaulay commented 3 years ago

Since this is a very robust lesson (lots of episodes!), I think it might be helpful to note which episode this comment relates to. I've just read through episodes 1-5 of the lesson, and they do not contain the activity of "reading the rubric before practicing teaching" so that means it could be in episodes 6-25.

I am not a maintainer of this lesson, so it's possible a maintainer of the lesson is so familiar with it that they can recognize what this issue is referring to without further guidance.

karenword commented 3 years ago

Thanks @emcaulay ! I think this issue lacks detail because it was posted by a Maintainer and has a primary audience of Trainers who are mostly familiar with the curriculum. This applies to our second live coding exercise, currently episode 17. We are working on a major update in a separate fork (something we may not do in the future as it lacks transparency for visitors) and I will tag this issue in when it has been addressed there.

emcaulay commented 3 years ago

Thanks for the information, @karenword. I just learned about the major update when I submitted an issue myself. Sounds like a big one! Good luck with the revisions.

As an instructor and a maintainer for a different lesson, I'm revisiting the instructor training lessons to improve my knowledge about the materials the ideas I learned during the instructor training. It's well worth re-reading, so thank you to all who work on this material!

brownsarahm commented 2 years ago

This also relates to #1178