search

cceh / ntg

Novum Testamentum Graecum
http://ntg.uni-muenster.de/
5 stars 6 forks source link

Potential Ancestors assigned incorrectly #111

Closed KWachtel closed 5 years ago

KWachtel commented 5 years ago

In Coherence in Attestations for Mc 13:15/2-4 c, the 4th potential ancestors of 1342 (namely c:03) is shown, but two others with higher ranks are skipped (a: 892 and a: 019). The list of Relatives of 1342 shows them as second and third pot. anc. with the same percentage of agreement. In such cases the witness with the higher ranking number and higher total of shared passages should be picked, in this case a:892.

MarcelloPerathoner commented 5 years ago

I can see no error here. 03 is inside the default connectivity of 5, and thus trumps all other ancestors. If you lower the connectivity to 3, 1342 will be assigned to 892.

KWachtel commented 5 years ago

Agreed. Sorry, I overlooked that 1342 and 03 share the same variant.