ccshiro / cc-buglist

Corecraft's issue tracker
43 stars 40 forks source link

Deathblow to the Legion #2374

Open Canderous opened 8 years ago

Canderous commented 8 years ago

After testing it rather extensively, these are our (mostly minor) remarks about the quest:

1) Kaylaan the Lost's healing ability should heal him for 50% of his hp according to wowhead data. Many wowhead comments warn about interrupting his heal and one of them (on the quest's comment page) states this, which also confirms that it should heal that much: "Tried this, but wasn't able to interrupt the heals. Cooldown on Intimidation is too long. I could handle the dps and healing my pet just fine, but the 1st boss kept healing to full." Here, he heals for 1-2% of his hp. The comments also state that he should start healing at 50%, here he starts earlier.

2) Ishanah is only auto-attacking and not using any of her abilities. According to the (quest's) comments section, in addition to the Holy Smite and Power Word:Shield listed on wowhead, she should also cast Greater Heal.

3) According to the item's description, Socrethar's Teleportation Stone is also supposed to be able to create a portal back from Socrethar's Seat. This should not initiate the Aldor NPC spawning though.

4) There is a typo in Kaylaan's speech: "hias hand" -> "his hand"; and another in Socrethar's speech: "bouth" -> "both".

5) If no one initiates the event after the Aldor NPCs spawned, they just stand there and do not despawn (at least not after 15 minutes), which makes completing the quest for the next Scryer players impossible as Socrethar is not attackable during this period.

6) There are two strange reset issues that I'm not sure if they are bugs or not. If the party wipes on Kaylaan, the event does not reset, and Kaylaan is attackable, which continues the event as intended. This looks strange but other than that it has no other effect. Also, if the #1 player on Socrethar's threat list runs away and makes him evade, Ishanah (and possibly the other NPCs if they are alive) will also evade and the event basically continues with all of them at full HP. There is nothing to be gained by this, it just looks strange when it happens. Maybe Socrethar should never leave his throne area?

ccshiro commented 8 years ago

3) According to the item's description, Socrethar's Teleportation Stone is also supposed to be able to create a portal back from Socrethar's Seat. This should not initiate the Aldor NPC spawning though.

Nor does it. Standing in the telportation device does, as it does on retail (tested this in particular when I made the quest).

5) If no one initiates the event after the Aldor NPCs spawned, they just stand there and do not despawn (at least not after 15 minutes), which makes completing the quest for the next Scryer players impossible as Socrethar is not attackable during this period.

That's odd, I made them despawn 2 minutes after spawning if the event doesn't get initiated. Will check what's wrong.

6) There are two strange reset issues that I'm not sure if they are bugs or not. If the party wipes on Kaylaan, the event does not reset, and Kaylaan is attackable, which continues the event as intended.

This is also how it works on retail, so not a bug.

Also, if the #1 player on Socrethar's threat list runs away and makes him evade, Ishanah (and possibly the other NPCs if they are alive) will also evade and the event basically continues with all of them at full HP. There is nothing to be gained by this, it just looks strange when it happens. Maybe Socrethar should never leave his throne area?

This too has the same behavior on retail.

Canderous commented 8 years ago

We checked the despawning after doing a successful event, so that may have influenced it.

EDIT: and also after one of us not completing but retaking the quest, because the NPCs only seemed to appear when the objective was not completed.

ccnim commented 8 years ago

Fixed Ishanah.