search

celzero / rethink-app

DNS over HTTPS / DNS over Tor / DNSCrypt client, WireGuard proxifier, firewall, and connection tracker for Android.
https://rethinkfirewall.com/
Apache License 2.0
2.6k stars 130 forks source link

[Enhancement request] No way to filter/see partly-allowed/blocked apps #1516

Open puelp opened 2 weeks ago

puelp commented 2 weeks ago

I block all apps by default, and only allow Internet access to a select few apps.

If I allow an app access to both Wi-Fi and mobile data, it will show up under the [Allowed] filter, which is great.

But if I allow an app access only to Wi-Fi or only to mobile data, it doesn't show up under [Allowed]!

Please make it so that partly-allowed apps show up under [Allowed], or have a new filter section called [Partly allowed].

Thank you very much in advance.

pandadeepimpact commented 2 weeks ago

I agree that having a filter to see those that only allow Wi-Fi or Mobile Data would be useful, though not when they're mixed together. How about having a separate filter of "Allowed on Unmetered" (Wi-Fi) and "Allowed on Metered" (Mobile Data) instead?

vovodroid commented 2 weeks ago

Probably defining default mode (allow or block) and just showing changed apps first would be simple approach.

ignoramous commented 4 days ago
  • When apps are allowed to connect on the cellular (metered) network but not on wifi networks the GUI Home tab shows all apps are blocked.
    Suggest GUI be modified to show how many apps are allowed by network type? img0:

Screenshot_20240621-131221_1

  • On the firewall's apps GUI itself there is no way to view a list of allowed apps if they are only allowed on the cellular (metered) network. The 'allowed' list only shows apps if they are allowed on both cellular and wifi networks.
    Suggest filters be added to show each apps blocked/allowed status by network type. img1:

Screenshot_20240621-140114_1

By @raven9nine from https://github.com/celzero/rethink-app/issues/1564#issue-2367107182