Current state of ObservatoryCore on Linux

cerus commented 1 year ago

Hello all,

the maintainer of ObservatoryCore, Xjph, has recently announced that Linux support will be completely dropped. They are planning on rewriting the UI with WinForms, which is not compatible with Linux. To directly quote Xjph from their post on the Frontier forums:

I originally chose AvaloniaUI as my UI framework because it [...] was compatible with both Windows and Linux [...]. Well no Linux build I ever did was in what I would consider a "releasable" state, and on top of that my use of AvaloniaUI has not really been a great time. For Linux users who were perhaps holding onto the hope of an official Linux release, this is unfortunately the final nail in the coffin for that particular goal. Sorry I never made it work.

This means that all future updates to ObservatoryCore will not be compatible with Linux. I will try to maintain a fork that keeps using Avalonia, but I can't guarantee anything. I don't know how much work it's going to be or if it is even possible, especially since I'm really not that skilled in C#.

Let me know your thoughts.

Ambient-Impact commented 5 months ago

That's really disappointing considering more of us continue to jump ship to Linux now that it's become a real and viable platform due to Valve's and other organizations' efforts. I'm a web developer, so it's a bit outside of my area of expertise, but I know of multiple cross platform toolkits, so it's strange to pick a Windows-only one at this point. Don't get me wrong, I fully appreciate that we're getting this for free by someone doing it in their spare time who doesn't owe us anything, so this more just frustration on my part seeing this wonderful tool put another barrier up for people like us wanting to move away from Windows.

That said, given that we've gotten the EDHM UI working on Linux - which I can confirm does indeed work once you jump through all the necessary hoops - the next best thing might just be to see if ObservatoryCore using the WinForms UI runs under Wine. Might save you some work.

Ambient-Impact commented 5 months ago

Wine update: it totally works:

Screenshot from 2024-04-02 02-32-16

Mind you, this is still with Avalonia so it'll be interesting to see if Wine can handle the WinForms version.

I'm planning on throwing together a script and a guide for how to do this for newbies, but the short version is:

Create a Wine prefix directory; in my case, I used ~/.wine-prefixes/elite-observatory-core
export WINEPREFIX="$HOME/.wine-prefixes/elite-observatory-core"
wine wineboot
winetricks win10
wine ~/Downloads/ObservatorySetup.exe

The only major issue is probably unrelated to this but the Observatory notifications always steal focus from my game which is incredibly annoying. That's more a GNOME issue though, so will document a fix if I find one.

cerus commented 5 months ago

Thank you for sharing your findings. The focus stealing thing is also a problem on KDE, my workaround was to simply set "Focus stealing prevention" to "High" whenever I used the app. Not sure if Gnome has a similar setting.

Ambient-Impact commented 5 months ago

Unfortunately, GNOME only seems to have a setting for things launched from a terminal but it doesn't do anything for anything launched in other ways. I'll have to keep looking, but I don't have high hopes at this point. The only alternative without switching to Plasma (which I may do at some point) seems to be to run Observatory in its own virtual desktop, which does prevent focus stealing but the big downside is that the notifications can't be displayed outside of the virtual desktop window, and so they're less useful.

Ambient-Impact commented 5 months ago

Also started using Bottles to sandbox and manage Wine stuff, and it does work very well for Observatory, so I recommend people use that instead of the manual method if only for the sake of security and that it's got a nice UI.

Note that the default runner is soda, which doesn't seem to work, but if you change the bottle runner to Wine, then it works perfectly.

Ambient-Impact commented 5 months ago

I don't know much about .NET stuff or desktop programming in general, but I do wonder how easy it would be hook into Observatory to alter those notifications, either completely disabling them and sending off their content to whatever native API for notifications exist in GNOME and other desktop managers, or worst case, we figure out how to watch for those notification windows being spawned and immediately return focus to the window or app that had focus just before.

Thinking farther ahead to the WinForms port that's planned, it looks like Wine uses something called Mono to run .NET stuff, and apparently Mono has a WinForms implementation, so maybe it'll just work?

cerus commented 5 months ago

I wrote a observatory core plugin a while ago that replaces these popup notifications with notifications from notify-send (from package libnotify on Arch). I'll see if I can find it on my drive, maybe it solves your issue.

Ambient-Impact commented 5 months ago

Heck yeah. That would be awesome. Will that work on the Windows build under Wine?

Mlippo commented 3 months ago

Thanks to all the discussion around this I got Observatory Core running under bottles. One thing I can't figure out is what font the Bioinsights plugin uses for the icons. Right now it's just the default white squares. Anyone have any ideas?