Closed cessda-bitbucket-importer closed 3 years ago
Original comment by Taina Jääskeläinen.
AuthEnty may be organisation in which case it may have different names in different languages. Affiliation attribute may also refer to the person’s organisation which again may be multilingual information.
In DDI 3.2 there are separate elements for organisations and persons but in DDI 2.5 both are put in AuthEnty element.
Original comment by Taina Jääskeläinen.
@darrenbell2 Rephrase Usage information. Something to the effect: Language of the organisation name, which may be AuthEnty or the person’s affiliation.
Original comment by Darren Bell (GitHub: darrenbell2).
From: Bell, Darren S
Sent: 26 November 2020 18:18
To: email address removed' <[email address removed](mailto:email address removed)>
Subject: RE: (CESSDA Metadata Office) Review of DDI profiles for CDC
Hi Benjamin. Thanks for the feedback.
https://github.com/cessda/cessda.metadata.profiles/issues/18
The usage of @xml:lang in this context will be changed to “Recommended” in the next version of the profile (v1.0.3 to be released in the next two weeks) and the documentation updated to reflect the fact that you are strongly encouraged to provide a language if it is an Organization name, but not for a Person.
see v1.0.2) recommends the use of “CESSDA Topic Classification” and “ELSST” for
Everyone, to help provide clarity when feeding back on the profiles (and feedback is very much appreciated), can you please ensure that you mention the version number of the profile you are reviewing.
This appears in the annotations at the top of the profile document e.g. ‘Version: v1.0.2’
Best wishes, Darren
From: Benjamin Peuch (Basecamp) [[mailto:email address removed](mailto:email address removed)]
Sent: 26 November 2020 15:21
To: Bell, Darren S <[email address removed](mailto:email address removed)>
Subject: Re: (CESSDA Metadata Office) Review of DDI profiles for CDC
Hello everybody,
I have a few questions and suggestions.
Like Johan , I'm not
sure why the xml:lang attribute should be mandatory for a person's name in the
Original comment by Darren Bell (GitHub: darrenbell2).
Changed @xml:lang to be Recommended for v1.0.3 of the 2.5 and 1.2.2 profile - see updated content below:
Original comment by Darren Bell (GitHub: darrenbell2).
Change implemented in drafted in v1.0.3 Needs final approval before closure of ticket and publishing v1.0.3
Original comment by Taina Jääskeläinen.
…or the @affiliation attribute of AuthEnty specifies a person.
Maybe rephrase or the @affiliation attribute when AuthEnty is a person.
Original report on BitBucket by Alexander Mühlbauer.
Feedback by Johan Marberg (SND)