cf-convention / vocabularies

Issues and source files for CF controlled vocabularies
3 stars 1 forks source link

Standard names: particle number size distribution terms #157

Closed markusfiebig closed 1 year ago

markusfiebig commented 3 years ago

Proposer's name Markus Fiebig Date 2021-09-22

markusfiebig commented 2 years ago

Since there aren't any comments, could these names be accepted?

JonathanGregory commented 2 years ago

Thanks for these proposals. It looks like you have been careful to use phrases already employed in existing standard names. They seem fine to me. Jonathan

feggleton commented 2 years ago

Thanks for your proposals. These have been added to the cfeditor (https://cfeditor.ceda.ac.uk/proposals/1). My only question would be (whilst thinking on the topic of stp) is, do we need both versions of the term or is there a way to have the term without referring to stp and reference this someone else in the metadata? If not, these seem fine to me.

markusfiebig commented 2 years ago

Hi Francesca,

I copy my response from task #129

I think we should add these terms as new ones. The new ones are definitely not aliases to the existing version with the STP statement. These versions should exist in parallel and serve different use cases. Once Allison progresses to atomising these terms according to I-ADOPT, the more specific versions will be connected to the less specific ones with skos:broader relations.

Regards, Markus

feggleton commented 2 years ago

Thanks for confirming. So if there are no further comments on these terms in the next 7 days then they can be accepted.

feggleton commented 2 years ago

Thanks these can now be accepted @japamment

japamment commented 1 year ago

Closing this issue as these names were published in V81 of the standard name table.