search

cgeo / WhereYouGo

Clone of the unmaintained repository (biylda/WhereYouGo) to continue app development
GNU General Public License v3.0
97 stars 40 forks source link

WhereYouGo no longer available for GARMIN Monterra #156

Open kurly1 opened 4 years ago

kurly1 commented 4 years ago

Describe the bug: Since the last update of WherYouGo the app is no longer available in the Goolge Play Store for GARMIN Monterra devices.

Version of WhereYouGo used: The Version 0.9.3 was available in the Google Play store for the Monterra device.

System information (Android version, device model): Monterra devices are still running on Ice Cream Sandwich (Android 4.0.4, API level 15).

Additional context: I think this issue might be caused trou the increasing of the minSdkVersion from 15 to 16 in the build.gradle.

Lineflyer commented 4 years ago

Monterra devices are still running on Ice Cream Sandwich (Android 4.0.4, API level 15).

Same problem as in c:geo. Say goodbye to those unmaintained devices...its a real shame for Garmin.

kurly1 commented 4 years ago

What was the reason that the supported API Level was raised from 15 to 16?

Because of the long battery run time this is still the best device to run Wherigo cartridges on.

Luckily I still have 0.9.3 on this device to run the cartridges.

bekuno commented 4 years ago

Many libraries are no more support api 15. And in the meantime the api 21 is now more realistic as minsdk for many apps and libs.

Maybe we can create a "legacy" version version 0.9.4 with only changes to https.

Lineflyer commented 4 years ago

That should be no problem: We have a legacy branch, which is equal to 0.9.3. So we just need to push the https fix commit on top of that.The question is only if the configured builder on CI can still build it.

bekuno commented 4 years ago

@kurly1 Please try this apk: https://ci.cgeo.org/job/whereyougo%20(PR)/261/artifact/build/outputs/apk/debug/whereyougo-PR183-2020.05.24-e232935-debug.apk

kurly1 commented 4 years ago

I installed this apk on my GARMIN Monterra and did the following tests:

I did not hat time to Play any Cardridge. And since c:geo is not available for this old Android version, I was not able to test the download of a cardridge from the WherYouGo app it selve. If any one can explain how to trigger a download manualy I will thest this as well.

Lineflyer commented 4 years ago

@kurly1 As you seem to have a Garmin Monterra on Android 4.0 available: We have now prepared an official legacy version to be published on Google Play. As I do not have an Android 4.0 device but only 4.1 could you please do me the favor to install and test this one: https://download.cgeo.org/whereyougo-legacy.apk It should show the version 2020.06.25-legacy and download features should work.

kurly1 commented 4 years ago

Exept the download Features the legacy Build seems to work. During the download I get a sslv3 handshake failure.

A download with the Chrome browser on this device is working. I don't know if the Chrome comes with a own newer implementation of the SSL as provided by Android 4.0. It seems that there was a change in in the SSL implementation between Android 4.0 and 4.1.

@Lineflyer Dos the download feature work on Android 4.1?

Lineflyer commented 4 years ago

AFAIK Chrome has its own implementation, which is the reason why it sill works while the system itself fails. I am however wondering that it worked for you with the first debug version (see comments above) but not with the newly compiled version....mmh.

Edit: Just now I read, that you did not test it with the first version. So I assume it would have had the same problem.

@jonas-koeritz AFAIR you proposed a change for cgeo to allow older devices to still connect (OKAPI). Do you think some similar workaround would be possible for this case here?

jonas-koeritz commented 4 years ago

Yep, this might actually work here as well. Maybe I've got that branch or code still around somewhere.

kurly1 commented 4 years ago

I didn't test the download wit the first debug version as mentioned in the comments above, because I didn't know how I could test it. I never used the download function bevor.

Wit "Cardrige can be loaded" I ment that the Cardrige can be opened (loaded in to the app).

For me, the download functionality is not importend in the legacy version. It's better to have a version without a download functionality than have no version at all.

Lineflyer commented 4 years ago

@jonas-koeritz If you find time, you are welcome. I will just wait a bit with releasing a legacy version. Maybe we get the download working as well?!

jonas-koeritz commented 4 years ago

I think I will have a look at this...just need to get my thoughts on that issue back together.

Lars notifications@github.com schrieb am Do., 2. Juli 2020, 21:01:

@jonas-koeritz https://github.com/jonas-koeritz If you find time, you are welcome. I will just wait a bit with releasing a legacy version. Maybe we get the download working as well?!

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/cgeo/WhereYouGo/issues/156#issuecomment-653172726, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABRPLCYVR7SPPTGMLMWLMMTRZTKRNANCNFSM4MI3T3VQ .

Lineflyer commented 4 years ago

@jonas-koeritz Shouldn't it be very similar to your pull request over at c:geo: https://github.com/cgeo/cgeo/pull/8139

Lineflyer commented 4 years ago

@jonas-koeritz Found any time meanwhile to take a look into this for the WhereYouGo legacy version (and quite similar for c:geo legacy version)?