search

chadmayfield / my-pihole-blocklists

Create custom pi-hole blocklists
GNU General Public License v3.0
334 stars 72 forks source link

Non-porn domains blocked #11

Closed KnightTim closed 5 years ago

KnightTim commented 5 years ago

I use both your lists with my pihole and noticed it was blocking a number of non-porn sites.

I was looking for something cute for my wife and noticed that Victoria Secret is blocked, it sells lingerie/underwear, it's not porn. Though, I can understand why some people would it blocked, as it can have provocative images. This got me curious, so with the help of google, I have a list of lingerie/underwear type sites that your list is blocking. My list is likely incomplete.

If you don't want to unblock them that is fine with me just close the issue, but I figured you should know.

victoriasecret.com www.victoriasecret.com fredericks.com www.fredericks.com barenecessities.com www.barenecessities.com yandy.com www.yandy.com lingeriediva.com www.lingeriediva.com lasenza.com www.lasenza.com amiclubwear.com www.amiclubwear.com forplaycatalog.com www.forplaycatalog.com spicylingerie.com www.spicylingerie.com dear-lover.com www.dear-lover.com hipsandcurves.com www.hipsandcurves.com smartandsexy.com www.smartandsexy.com herroom.com www.herroom.com petitecherry.com www.petitecherry.com torrid.com www.torrid.com

This one is a magazine, I'm pretty sure it isn't even adult focused ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refinery29 ) refinery29.com www.refinery29.com

chadmayfield commented 5 years ago

I agree, based on legal definitions of pornography these sites don't apply (otherwise I'd have to block Amazon as well for selling lingerie);

Pornography is the portrayal of erotic behavior designed to cause sexual excitement. It is words, acts, or representations that are calculated to stimulate sex feelings independent of the presence of another loved and chosen human being. It is divorced from reality in its sole purpose to stimulate erotic response. It is preoccupied with and concentrates on sex organs for the purpose of sexual stimulation. It emphasizes them and focuses on them in varying ways calculated to incite sexual desire.

As I've stated before, these sites are blocked upstream. The best I can do is add them to the exclude list so they don't find themselves in my lists. Thanks for taking the time to file a bug report. I'll update the lists accordingly.