channotation / chap

CHAP is a tool for the functional annotation of ion channel structures:
http://www.channotation.org
Other
18 stars 10 forks source link

How to use CHAP on multiple ion channels #35

Closed cgseitz closed 3 years ago

cgseitz commented 3 years ago

Hello,

I am wanting to use CHAP with my system, which contains several putative ion channels. What is the best way to go about this? From reading the documentation, I can think of a few ideas:

1) Run CHAP multiple times, with each time setting the -pf-init-probe-pos to be over each ion channel 2) Slice my trajectories so that each one just contains one ion channel 3) Tell CHAP that there are multiple ion channels in the system (unclear exactly how to do this, would need syntax examples)

What would you recommend? This is a huge system, is why I'm asking for your recommendations instead of trying each of these. Thanks in advance!

Best, Christian

Inniag commented 3 years ago

Hi Christian, thanks for reaching out.

Unfortunately, CHAP can not identify multiple pathways simultaneously, which rules out your option number 3. The other two options should both work and it is up to your personal preference which one you chose. The -pf-init-probe-pos exists for this purpose, but I have found it can sometimes be easier for scripting purposes to just position the ion channel in the box so that the center of the pore lies in the origin. How easy this would be in your case, you are in the best position to judge.

Hope this helps and best of luck with your research!