chaotic-aur / packages

Read-only mirror of Chaotic-AUR's main repository. Issues and bug reports welcome! 📑
https://gitlab.com/chaotic-aur/pkgbuilds
GNU General Public License v3.0
338 stars 20 forks source link

[Request] firefox-extension-adguard #3280

Closed encode42 closed 2 months ago

encode42 commented 2 months ago

Package:

https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/firefox-extension-adguard

Purpose:

Provides the AdGuard ad-blocker extension for Firefox installations.

Benefits:

Though uBlock Origin is often recommended, AdGuard is a very worthy alternative. Additionally, compared to managing extension updates through the browser, user such as myself would like to defer to the system's package manager.

Building:

No response

Copyright:

GPL-3.0-only

Expected Interest:

Only me

Already available?

No

Unique request?

Yes

Banned package?

No

More information:

No response

xiota commented 2 months ago

Inclined to reject because extensions should be managed directly through the browser.

encode42 commented 2 months ago

The Chaotic-AUR already provides multiple Firefox extensions, though. I would agree, if these didn't already exist on Chaotic's repository. The AdGuard extension is one that is on the AUR but not built by Chaotic, while others like firefox-extension-localcdn and firefox-extension-plasma-integration are.

However, I won't deny that it's uncommon for extensions to be managed outside of the browser. If this is closed because of this, I'd completely understand. I just saw that similar projects were already being hosted by the Chaotic-AUR, and decided to request one that had been missing.

xiota commented 2 months ago

I see only those two extensions for a few different browsers. There used to be more, but they were gradually dropped. The last several had been deleted from AUR following poor maintenance. The pace of web development makes them difficult to keep updated, and when outdated, they block the usual installation and update methods.