chili-epfl / chilitags

Robust Fiducial Markers for Augmented Reality And Robotics
http://chili.epfl.ch/software
123 stars 57 forks source link

Markerless pose estimation #58

Closed severin-lemaignan closed 9 years ago

severin-lemaignan commented 9 years ago

...for chilitags-3...

Resources:

qbonnard commented 9 years ago

That's a pretty nihilist enhancement... Chilitags 3, a markerless fiducial marker library. Seriously, what would be the intersection between Chilitags and markerless pose estimation ?

ayberkozgur commented 9 years ago

Nothing I guess, but what's wrong with having no intersection?

severin-lemaignan commented 9 years ago

nihilist enhancement

Nicely said! I may reuse that in other projects :-)

I agree that implementing such a feature would require a change in chilitags' tagline. But AFAIK, fiducial markers are just a subset of generic patterns, and if the initial (and only?) point of using them was robustness, I believe we should reconsider that design choice in light of the ~10y of advancements in feature detection.

qbonnard commented 9 years ago

Did you both leave your computer unlocked ? ;) How about integrating a bittorrent tracker too ?

So in the case you were serious, I'd refer to the "do one thing, do it well" philosophy which I think is important for a library. How about moving this issue to qimchi ? I feel it fits the scope better.

qbonnard commented 9 years ago

Ah I see. So it would be more an improvement of the tracking part of chilitags ?

skadge commented 9 years ago

chilitrack is a first attempt at implementing such a marker-less AR lib.

ayberkozgur commented 9 years ago

So no that we have chilitrack development started, closing this issue?

qbonnard commented 9 years ago

Yup, we'll reopen a "merge chilitrack" issue