search

chise / ids

Mirror of https://gitlab.chise.org/CHISE/ids
https://www.chise.org/ids/
12 stars 3 forks source link

Use '⿱𥫗x' to Replace '⿱竹x' #6

Open mumchristmas opened 3 years ago

mumchristmas commented 3 years ago

𥫗 (U-00025AD7) is already in the IDS-UCS-Ext-B-3. But with the (maybe) wrong ids formula:

U-00025AD7 𥫗 竹 (U+7AF9)

http://en.glyphwiki.org/wiki/u25ad7 http://en.glyphwiki.org/wiki/u7af9 As this will be a big change to all the glyphs with ⿱竹x(2062 matches across 21 files). Maybe we shall discuss it first.

mumchristmas commented 3 years ago

And we also get：

U+2F75 ⽵ (Kangxi Radical Bamboo)

http://en.glyphwiki.org/wiki/u2f75 This is also not inconsistent with the actual writing of the glyphs.

Yukinoroh commented 1 month ago

I think it's a nice idea. 竹 is different from 𥫗, as 心 differs from 忄. Also, 𥫗 would help identifying the radical. I believe the reason it is 竹 is because the database predates Unicode's Extension B.

But how about 𥯵 ? 竹 is not at the top but yet it is the radical.

By the way, we would need to consider ⿳竹xx and as well. (And maybe ⿳xx竹!) And checking for cases where x starts with a descriptor. Not an easy task!

For consistency, we could change U+7A79 to the radical U+2F75 in cases like this: U+2E164 𮅤 ⿰竹查 U+2E197 𮆗 ⿰竹落 (I only see two of them, but I also see: U-00025DF9 𥷹 ⿱⿰竹竹⿰竹竹 U-00025D12 𥴒 ⿱竹⿰竹竹 )