chr56 / Phonograph_Plus

A fork of kabouzeid/Phonograph in maintenance and development
GNU General Public License v3.0
367 stars 19 forks source link

[Bug] Low quality artwork in notification area. #202

Closed perrsona1234 closed 1 month ago

perrsona1234 commented 1 month ago

Bug Summary

Song's artwork in notification area is of low quality. I had similar problem with song's artwork in the app, but I have solved it by disabling "Android MediaStore" in image source configuration (per recommendations I have found in other reported issues). However this didn't solve the problem of low quality of notification area artwork.

Version

1.7.2.1

Steps to reproduce the bug

  1. Open the app.
  2. Play a song with an artwork.
  3. Pull down the notification area.
  4. Artwork is of low quality.

Environment

Phone: Moto E7 Power Android OS version: 10 ROM: Official from Motorola without any modifications

Screenshots or Screen recordings

Here is a screenshot of the problem compared to two other apps: Auxio (music player) and PipePipe (a fork of NewPipe). Screenshot_20240717-121831

Other helpful information

No response

chr56 commented 1 month ago

Since Android R (11), Phonograph Plus provides high quality artwork via MediaSession Metadata to System (before that version, it uses only Notification LargeIcon with limited size). This is because vanilla AOSP use images from MediaSession since R (the improved Media Notification as a "new feature" when marketing[^nf]).

However, it looks that your device vendor makes some changes of the vanilla. It seems that:

Actually, this behavior is distinct from vanilla AOSP. I am not willing to modify Phonograph Plus for that. But, I may provide a option in settings for compatibility in future.

[^nf]: Android 11 Displays Multiple Media Player Cards Simultaneously, And Android 11 - Playing nicely with media controls

chr56 commented 1 month ago

In Preview version v1.8.1-dev1, there is an option to always use Media Session to display images in Section Compatibility.

Please check it whether it can help you for your situation.

perrsona1234 commented 1 month ago

No, it didn't fix my problem.

chr56 commented 1 month ago

What about this revision: PhonographPlus

perrsona1234 commented 1 month ago

This one fixed my problem. Thanks.

Screenshot_20240728-094336

chr56 commented 1 month ago

v1.8.1 has been released!

Close!