search

chrisisbeef / jquery-encoder

Contextual Output Encoding for jQuery
MIT License
86 stars 25 forks source link

Problems with Visual Studio 2015 and Microsoft Edge #14

Closed paulguz closed 8 years ago

paulguz commented 9 years ago

Hi,

jquery-encoder seems to be causing problems in Microsoft Edge, and Visual Studio 2015.

I can't describe the problem in Edge as it goes away when debugging, except that Edge may refuse to load a web application that uses encoder.js.

If encoder.js is present in any Visual Studio 2015 project, VS2015 crashes when attempting to edit any JavaScript file.

MIcrosoft have been informed and are actively investigating the VS2015 issue.

Regards,

Paul

patrickkettner commented 9 years ago

@paulguz can you provide an example of the issue with edge?

paulguz commented 9 years ago

@patrickkettner, thanks for responding.

I've set up a version of our software at http://datapadev2.cloudapp.net/datapa/.

You'll see the problem in Edge straight away. Disappointingly there problem does not occur if you open the F12 dev tool, and there are no console errors (a few warnings, but nothing relevant).

ldrick commented 9 years ago

Hello, I ran into the same problem, it seems Edge reloads the page twice or more and fails. With debugger-console open, the Edge won't have any problems. This is my question to the Edge team: https://connect.microsoft.com/IE/feedback/details/1662734/edge-cant-display-page-if-javascript-library-jquery-encoder-will-be-loaded-via-jquery

Oooops, I have to answer them back - didn't got any mail or something o.O Maybe @paulguz you can answer with your link?

paulguz commented 9 years ago

@ketamin , I've commented on your Microsoft Connect post. Please note I've moved my example to http://datapadev2.cloudapp.net/DataPAEncoder/

Glad to see that it's not just me.

chrisisbeef commented 9 years ago

Great to see you guys working on this - keep us posted here of any progress you make on this issue please!

patrickkettner commented 9 years ago

@paulguz the domain seems to be down - can you double check?

paulguz commented 9 years ago

@patrickkettner It's back up now; sorry for the slow response, I've been away.

Note the change in URL from my original response to you. It is now

http://datapadev2.cloudapp.net/DataPAEncoder/

paulguz commented 8 years ago

Good news: with the November update to Windows 10, it seems that the problem with Edge is now gone. Also, I've been informed by Microsoft that the problem with Visual Studio 2015 is also fixed with Update 1 (although I've not tried it yet as it is still at RC stage).

@ketamin, have you run the November update yet and if so, can you confirm the problem has gone?

chrisisbeef commented 8 years ago

@paulguz @ketamin @patrickkettner - Can one of you confirm that this issue is resolved? It seems like it has been determined with relative confidence that this is an upstream issue, so I would like to close this issue out if that's okay with you all.

paulguz commented 8 years ago

@chrisisbeef For me, the problem is gone, in both Edge and Visual Studio 2015.

chrisisbeef commented 8 years ago

Closing issue - thanks for following up on this @paulguz @ketamin @patrickkettner