search

ciaa / firmware_v1

Firmware de la CIAA
http://www.proyecto-ciaa.com.ar
126 stars 120 forks source link

lwip + lpcopen: compiling for board differents than ciaa_nxp fails with no descriptive error message. #423

Closed mabeett closed 7 years ago

mabeett commented 8 years ago

Since externals/lwip/inc/arch/ and externals/lwip/src/arch/ are visible for any board when the user calls make for the blinking_lwip example the compiling fails getting chip.h headers.

chip.h file is only available for lpc43xx CPUTYPE

$ make 

===============================================================================
Compiling c file: ./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c

gcc -c -Wall -ggdb3 -DCIAA_CFG_NET_IP -c -Wall -ggdb3  -Iexamples/blinking_lwip/inc  -I./modules/posix/inc  -I./modules/ciaak/inc  -I./modules/drivers/inc  -I./modules/drivers/x86/inc  -I./modules/drivers/x86/ia64/inc  -I./modules/drivers/x86/ia64/none/inc  -I./externals/drivers/inc  -I./externals/drivers/x86/inc  -I./externals/drivers/x86/ia64/inc  -I./externals/drivers/x86/ia64/inc/device  -I./externals/drivers/x86/ia64/none/inc  -I./modules/rtos/inc  -I./modules/rtos/inc/x86  -I./modules/rtos/inc/x86/ia64  -I./out/gen/inc  -I./out/gen/inc/x86  -I./out/gen/inc/x86/ia64  -I./modules/libs/inc  -I./modules/libs/inc/x86  -I./modules/libs/inc/x86/ia64  -I./externals/lwip/inc  -I./externals/lwip/inc/ipv4  -I./modules/base/inc  -I./modules/base/x86/inc  -I./modules/base/x86/ia64/inc  -I./modules/base/x86/ia64/none/inc  -I./externals/base/inc  -I./externals/base/x86/inc  -I./externals/base/x86/ia64/inc  -I./externals/base/x86/ia64/none/inc -DARCH=x86 -DCPUTYPE=ia64 -DCPU=none -DBOARD=ciaa_sim_ia64 ./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c -o ./out/obj/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.o
In file included from ./externals/lwip/inc/lwip/arch.h:43:0,
                 from ./externals/lwip/inc/lwip/debug.h:35,
                 from ./externals/lwip/inc/lwip/opt.h:46,
                 from ./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c:32:
./externals/lwip/inc/arch/cc.h:61:0: warning: "BYTE_ORDER" redefined [enabled by default]
 #define BYTE_ORDER LITTLE_ENDIAN
 ^
In file included from /usr/include/x86_64-linux-gnu/sys/types.h:216:0,
                 from ./modules/base/inc/ciaaPOSIX_stddef.h:77,
                 from ./modules/posix/inc/ciaaPOSIX_stdlib.h:51,
                 from examples/blinking_lwip/inc/lwipopts.h:119,
                 from ./externals/lwip/inc/lwip/opt.h:45,
                 from ./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c:32:
/usr/include/endian.h:48:0: note: this is the location of the previous definition
 # define BYTE_ORDER __BYTE_ORDER
 ^
./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c:45:18: fatal error: chip.h: No existe el archivo o el directorio
 #include "chip.h"
                  ^
compilation terminated.
make: *** [lpc18xx_43xx_emac.o] Error 1

$ make info| grep -i board  | head -n 1
BOARD/ARCH/CPUTYPE/CPU...: ciaa_sim_ia64/x86/ia64/none
$ find -name chip.h 
./out/download/lpcopen_2_16/lpc_chip_43xx/inc/chip.h
./out/download/lpcopen_2_16/lpc_chip_43xx_m0/inc/chip.h
mabeett commented 8 years ago

Work in progress

mcerdeiro commented 8 years ago

Lwip is only ported to nxp. Is not a bug but a feature. Nobody tried to port Lwip to other board right now. Am 01.07.2016 6:32 AM schrieb "MAbeeTT (Matías Pecchia)" < notifications@github.com>:

Since externals/lwip/inc/arch/ and externals/lwip/src/arch/ are visible for any board when the user calls make for the blinking_lwip example the compiling fails getting chip.h headers.

chip.h file is only available for lpc43xx CPUTYPE

$ make

Compiling c file: ./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c

gcc -c -Wall -ggdb3 -DCIAA_CFG_NET_IP -c -Wall -ggdb3 -Iexamples/blinking_lwip/inc -I./modules/posix/inc -I./modules/ciaak/inc -I./modules/drivers/inc -I./modules/drivers/x86/inc -I./modules/drivers/x86/ia64/inc -I./modules/drivers/x86/ia64/none/inc -I./externals/drivers/inc -I./externals/drivers/x86/inc -I./externals/drivers/x86/ia64/inc -I./externals/drivers/x86/ia64/inc/device -I./externals/drivers/x86/ia64/none/inc -I./modules/rtos/inc -I./modules/rtos/inc/x86 -I./modules/rtos/inc/x86/ia64 -I./out/gen/inc -I./out/gen/inc/x86 -I./out/gen/inc/x86/ia64 -I./modules/libs/inc -I./modules/libs/inc/x86 -I./modules/libs/inc/x86/ia64 -I./externals/lwip/inc -I./externals/lwip/inc/ipv4 -I./modules/base/inc -I./modules/base/x86/inc -I./modules/base/x86/ia64/inc -I./modules/base/x86/ia64/none/inc -I./externals/base/inc -I./externals/base/x86/inc -I./externals/base/x86/ia64/inc -I./externals/base/x86/ia64/none/inc -DARCH=x86 -DCPUTYPE=ia64 -DCPU=none -DBOARD=ciaa_sim_ia64 ./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c -o ./out/obj/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.o In file included from ./externals/lwip/inc/lwip/arch.h:43:0, from ./externals/lwip/inc/lwip/debug.h:35, from ./externals/lwip/inc/lwip/opt.h:46, from ./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c:32: ./externals/lwip/inc/arch/cc.h:61:0: warning: "BYTE_ORDER" redefined [enabled by default]

define BYTE_ORDER LITTLE_ENDIAN

^ In file included from /usr/include/x86_64-linux-gnu/sys/types.h:216:0, from ./modules/base/inc/ciaaPOSIX_stddef.h:77, from ./modules/posix/inc/ciaaPOSIX_stdlib.h:51, from examples/blinking_lwip/inc/lwipopts.h:119, from ./externals/lwip/inc/lwip/opt.h:45, from ./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c:32: /usr/include/endian.h:48:0: note: this is the location of the previous definition

define BYTE_ORDER __BYTE_ORDER

^ ./externals/lwip/src/arch/lpc18xx_43xx_emac.c:45:18: fatal error: chip.h: No existe el archivo o el directorio

include "chip.h"

              ^

compilation terminated. make: *\ [lpc18xx_43xx_emac.o] Error 1

$ make info| grep -i board | head -n 1 BOARD/ARCH/CPUTYPE/CPU...: ciaa_sim_ia64/x86/ia64/none $ find -name chip.h ./out/download/lpcopen_2_16/lpc_chip_43xx/inc/chip.h ./out/download/lpcopen_2_16/lpc_chip_43xx_m0/inc/chip.h

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ciaa/Firmware/issues/423, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe/AG7km930gXaX5CHwyfnrT4C7phoqZ6AIks5qRJg8gaJpZM4JCz1e .

mcerdeiro commented 8 years ago

Para mi hay que cerrar este issue y crearlo cuando alguien quiera ocuparse del tema para otro board. Am 01.07.2016 6:32 AM schrieb "MAbeeTT (Matías Pecchia)" < notifications@github.com>:

Work in progress

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ciaa/Firmware/issues/423#issuecomment-229851657, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe/AG7km7a6vPGn15ZTEU6BjXLJSzl45WE_ks5qRJhHgaJpZM4JCz1e .

mabeett commented 8 years ago

Lwip is only ported to nxp. Is not a bug but a feature. Nobody tried to port Lwip to other board right now

pc18xx_43xx_emac.c:45:18: fatal error: chip.h does not seem being a feature related with the user. I am working in this bug particular feature.

Para mi hay que cerrar este issue y crearlo cuando alguien quiera ocuparse del tema para otro board.

Me quiero ocupar para todos los boads. Work in progress. Estoy en eso. A la fecha saldría incompatinle con el otro MR (pero compatible con el actual master). Si el otro MR prospera antes, adecuaré los cambios.

mabeett commented 8 years ago

El hecho de que esté trabajando en esto es para limpiar el directorio arch de los directorios de lwip, entonces lograría llamar a lwip como submódulo del git repositoprio oficial de LWIP. http://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/lwip.git/

Ya probé lwip 1.4.1 del upstream y funciona (no ipv6 aún). Para probar la version 2.0.0 (beta) se trataría solamente de actualizar el módulo.

mabeett commented 7 years ago

solved in #427 & #428