search

cinnyapp / cinny

Yet another matrix client
https://cinny.in
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
1.87k stars 242 forks source link

Better direct message room management #237

Open viasux opened 2 years ago

viasux commented 2 years ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.

Room management is hell for anyone using matrix currently. I have not seen a single matrix client do room management in a "good" way imho. I run multiple chat bridges on my matrix server, meaning I have hundreds of chats which are hard to sort through. When I click the "Direct messages" section on cinny, I am presented with every single bridged chat, un-categorized.

Describe the solution you'd like

I would prefer if direct messages which are manually put into a space stay in the space, and not appear on the "direct messages" section. Also, an option to then sort direct messages by activity (https://github.com/ajbura/cinny/issues/54) would be wonderful.

Describe alternatives you've considered

My workaround on element is to put them all in spaces, and set them all to low priority, so they are hidden under my other chats in the "people" section of element. However, this is not ideal, the "low priority" option can be confusing, and imho shouldn't exist. It's a bandaid fix for a much larger problem. I see no functional workaround for this issue in cinny at this time.

kfiven commented 2 years ago

"Home" and "Direct messages" are part of app where you can find every chat despite them being in other spaces. For example one can pin space and create a shortcut but it still can be opened via Home.

Also about the space, user could leave them but that doesn't close DMs with other users.

About the sorting part, I agree that activity based sorting will be really helpful.

ajbura commented 2 years ago

We have DMs sorting by activity now but I don't think removing DM's from People tab (if they are added in a space) will be great as I often find myself struggling to remember that which space consist which DM and end up looking for that in People tab (and I have got same feedback from few others as well).

viasux commented 2 years ago

We have DMs sorting by activity now but I don't think removing DM's from People tab (if they are added in a space) will be great as I often find myself struggling to remember that which space consist which DM and end up looking for that in People tab (and I have got same feedback from few others as well).

oh yes I wasn't advocating for that lol, don't separate dm's in a space

viasux commented 2 years ago

wait yes i was i dont know why i thought that would be a good idea wtf

viasux commented 2 years ago

OHH it was because I had bridges for telegram/discord and I wanted a way to categorize them.. I was meaning like only if they were manually added by the user to like a private space, for categorization

Folder functionality could solve this issue as well.

kfiven commented 2 years ago

You can add DMs to a space in Cinny as well but we still keep them in People tab. So if I get it correctly this issue is about "Remove DMs from People tab if they are added to a space"?

viasux commented 1 year ago

You can add DMs to a space in Cinny as well but we still keep them in People tab. So if I get it correctly this issue is about "Remove DMs from People tab if they are added to a space"?

yes - also simple folder functionality could accomplish the same end goal of being able to categorize dm's

viasux commented 1 year ago

in fact I believe I would prefer a folder system to a system reliant on spaces..