Feedback

[abelsiqueira]

General information

• @lyashevska's feedback
• Version 2.1.0
• First time seeing the application in use

Landing

• Looks good.
• Button says "Create" but the text above says "Generate". Should probably be the same. (#791)

Start

• Does not like errors from the start without doing anything. (#399)
• It is not clear at first that Tabbing from input goes to the info button, instead of going to the next input. (#793)
• What is the message default (use placeholder?) (#794)
• The purpose of the message is not clear (#794)

Author

• Have the fields directly available, i.e., give the form straight away. (#795)
• The role of done is not clear. Was expecting both "add author" and "done" to create (i.e., it is only created after "submitting"). (#795)
• Shouldn’t be able to add empty authors (#795)
• Clicking on the card should open edit mode (#796)

Identifiers

• same issues as authors (#795)

Related Resources

• Should related resources support git? (Comment by @abelsiqueira: I think the other kind of link is for SSH protocol, so it requires permissions to be accessed, which means that the link would not be useful).
• It is still not clear what "other repository" is supposed to mean. (#797)

Keywords

• Bug: Keyword enter deletes the keyword. (#798)
• Keyword enter should accept the keyword and create a new one. (#623)

Version specific

• Clearer date error (MM is 01-12 and DD is 01-31) (#799)

Finish

• Congratulations means end, i.e., was induced to think that the form was over (related to #444, #445, #648)

General

• It is nice that there is a preview (opposite of #671)
• The CITATION.cff should only be available if it is valid (#800)
• Would prefer persistent “done” in stepper, i.e., if after going to a screen, goes back, then it remains "blue" (#801)
• Optional screens were not clear
• “Do the info buttons help? Are they natural?”
  • Yes, they were helpful.

[abelsiqueira]

Issues were created or related to this feedback. Closing it.