search

citizenos / citizenos-fe

5 stars 2 forks source link

IDEATION: User preference for seeing who has up or downvoted idea replies (and ideas?) #1280

Closed BeccaMelhuish closed 2 weeks ago

BeccaMelhuish commented 3 months ago

@kevincrepin @ilmartyrk

Only from 1 user, but seeing as we have it already for discussions, seems it would be consistent and hopefully technically easy to add?

Insights from Round 1 ideation admin UX tests

One admin said he would like to be able to see who has liked or disliked an idea reply, to get a better sense of the discussion. I assume he'd also want to see who has upvoted (lightbulbed) an idea, but he only mentioned it for the up and down on replies. So am not sure on that. The use case was for internal decision-making in a youth social movement.

Suggestion:

Add this feature like we have in discussions? Though this would be a pop up over a pop up, so maybe not working?

BeccaMelhuish commented 3 months ago

Actually I just noticed from another test recording that this was already possible? So I think it must have been either a bug or a UX issue that meant the user above didn't find how to do this, i.e. here:

image

But will leave this issue open anyway, in case we want to add a way for users to see who has 'lightbulbed' the idea - as this would be more consistent then (and arguably more important to see that than to see who reacted to a reply). Not sure how we would do it though, as clicking here is already an action (to toggle it on/off).

image

kevincrepin commented 3 months ago

I fixed it now in the latest iteration of the "insightful" bulb:

Screenshot 2024-06-07 at 15 14 59 Screenshot 2024-06-07 at 15 15 06

BeccaMelhuish commented 3 months ago

Ah though @kevincrepin he actually wanted to see which people in particular had liked it, like we have with the discussion and vote replies, when you click it and you get this:

image

Though just to clarify, the user actually mentioned this in relation to the idea replies (which for some reason he wasn't seeing), I've just made the assumption that if he wanted it for that he would have wanted it for the idea likes (seems more necessary for that, and a bit inconsistent if we show it for replies but not for the main idea?).

kevincrepin commented 3 months ago

Yes, we can reuse that logic: just click on the number and this dialog window would open.

BeccaMelhuish commented 3 months ago

Ah got it, yes that's good thank you!

ilmartyrk commented 2 months ago

@kevincrepin @BeccaMelhuish I replaced the thumb-up icon with the lightbulb for this dialog

BeccaMelhuish commented 2 months ago

This seems done to me so moving it to testing in case @ssin1901 needs to test anything, but from my side seems good :)

ssin1901 commented 2 months ago

@BeccaMelhuish this is how it currently works (see screen recording). If all fine, then you can close the issue.

https://github.com/citizenos/citizenos-fe/assets/72747107/11a3ea61-a1be-4e09-9f6d-c2d45ac34c9c

ssin1901 commented 3 weeks ago

@BeccaMelhuish I think this issue can be closed?